Which among the following statements are correct about lessons learnt from the experience of the Emergency?
(A) Internal Emergency can be proclaimed only on the grounds of 'armed rebellion' and it is necessary that the advice to the President to proclaim Emergency must be given in writing by the Union Cabinet.
(B) The Courts have assumed a proactive role in protecting the civil liberties of the individuals.
(C) There is a tension between routine functioning of a democratic government and the continuous political protests by parties and groups.
(D) According to Balwant Rai Commission Report, the administration and the police become vulnerable to political pressures in this context.
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → (A), (B) and (C) only
(A) Internal Emergency can be proclaimed only on the grounds of ‘armed rebellion’ and it is necessary that the advice to the President to proclaim Emergency must be given in writing by the Union Cabinet. Correct. The Emergency brought out ambiguities in the Emergency provision of the Constitution that have since been rectified in this way.
(B) The Courts have assumed a proactive role in protecting the civil liberties of the individuals. Correct. The Emergency made everyone more aware of the value of civil liberties, and the Courts have taken an active role after the Emergency in protecting them, in response to the judiciary’s inability to do so during the Emergency.
(C) There is a tension between routine functioning of a democratic government and the continuous political protests by parties and groups. Correct. Among the issues that the critical years of Emergency brought out is this tension between routine functioning and continuous protests, and the question of what the correct balance between the two should be.
(D) According to Balwant Rai Commission Report, the administration and the police become vulnerable to political pressures in this context. Incorrect. The finding is right, but the report is not: it was the Shah Commission Report that said the administration and the police became vulnerable to political pressures during the Emergency.
Note: The Balwant Rai Mehta Committee (1957) is known for its report on rural local government, which recommended the three-tier Panchayati Raj system; it had nothing to do with the Emergency. It is not in any of the NCERT books, the pre-rationalised, 2023-24, 2025-26 or 2026-27 edition; it is mentioned here for the benefit of the students.
NCERT (2026-27): “Lessons of the Emergency … Secondly, it brought out some ambiguities regarding the Emergency provision in the Constitution that have been rectified since. Now, ‘internal’ Emergency can be proclaimed only on the grounds of ‘armed rebellion’ and it is necessary that the advice to the President to proclaim Emergency must be given in writing by the Union Cabinet. Thirdly, the Emergency made everyone more aware of the value of civil liberties. The Courts too, have taken an active role after the Emergency in protecting the civil liberties of the individuals.… Lessons of the Emergency … However, the critical years of emergency brought many issues that have not been adequately grappled with. We have noted in this chapter that there is a tension between routine functioning of a democratic government and the continuous political protests by parties and groups. What is the correct balance between the two? Should the citizens have full freedom to engage in protest activity or should they have no such right at all? What are the limits to such a protest? Secondly, the actual implementation of the Emergency rule took place through the police and the administration. These institutions could not function independently. They were turned into political instruments of the ruling party and according to the Shah Commission Report, the administration and the police became vulnerable to political pressures. This problem did not vanish after the Emergency.” |