For constructing the history of 'Partition' which among the following can be considered as archival sources?
(A) Memoirs
(B) Diaries
(C) Libraries
(D) Newspapers
(E) Government Reports
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → (A), (B), (D), (E) only
(A) Memoirs — Correct. Memoirs are first-hand written accounts, one of the materials from which the history of Partition has been constructed.
(B) Diaries — Correct. Diaries, like memoirs and family histories, record what people went through and help us understand the trials and tribulations of ordinary people during Partition.
(C) Libraries — Incorrect. A library is a place where records are kept, not itself a record of the events, so it is not a source.
(D) Newspapers — Correct. Newspapers of the time are records of the events as they happened and are kept in archives.
(E) Government Reports — Correct. Government reports and files throw ample light on the negotiations between the British and the political parties and on the rehabilitation of refugees.
Note 1: The word ‘archival’ and newspapers as a source of Partition are not in the pre-rationalised NCERT. The book names memoirs, diaries and government reports and files among the sources; newspapers of the time, kept in archives, are records of the same kind, while a library is only a place where such records are kept. Explained here for the benefit of the students.
Note 2: This question is taken from the chapter ‘Understanding Partition’ which was there in the pre-rationalised NCERT and has been deleted from subsequent editions of NCERT, including the NCERT book (2026-27).
NCERT (Pre-rationalised): “5.2 Preserving ‘honour’ … Have you taken note of the materials from which the history of Partition has been constructed in this chapter? Oral narratives, memoirs, diaries, family histories, first-hand written accounts – all these help us understand the trials and tribulations of ordinary people during the partition of the country.… 2.1 Partition or holocaust? … It is impossible to extract this kind of information from government documents. The latter deal with policy and party matters and various state-sponsored schemes. In the case of Partition, government reports and files as well as the personal writings of its high-level functionaries throw ample light on negotiations between the British and the major political parties about the future of India or on the rehabilitation of refugees.…” |