Identify which of the following is an odd one in the context of the circumstances for the Proclamation of National Emergency in 1975?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → Findings of the Shah Commission
Option (1) Nav Nirman Samiti — A circumstance before 1975. In January 1974 students in Gujarat started an agitation, the Nav Nirman movement, against rising prices of food grains, cooking oil and other essential commodities, and against corruption in high places. It led to President’s rule in the State and to fresh elections in June 1975.
Option (2) Agitation against Corruption in Bihar — A circumstance before 1975. In March 1974 students in Bihar protested against rising prices, food scarcity, unemployment and corruption, and invited Jayaprakash Narayan to lead them; he gave a call for total revolution.
Option (3) Findings of the Shah Commission — Odd one out. The Shah Commission was appointed in 1977 by the Janata Party government, after the Emergency, to inquire into its excesses. Its findings came after the Emergency, so they could not be a circumstance for proclaiming it.
Option (4) Allahabad High Court’s Judgement — A circumstance before 1975. On 12 June 1975, Justice Jagmohan Lal Sinha of the Allahabad High Court declared Indira Gandhi’s election to the Lok Sabha invalid; the Emergency was declared on 25 June 1975.
Note: The name ‘Nav Nirman’ is not in the NCERT books – the pre-rationalised, 2023-24, 2025-26 or 2026-27 edition; they describe the same students’ agitation in Gujarat of 1974 without naming it. The name is explained here for the benefit of the students.
NCERT (2026-27): “Gujarat and Bihar movements … In January 1974 students in Gujarat started an agitation against rising prices of food grains, cooking oil and other essential commodities, and against corruption in high places. The students’ protest was joined by major opposition parties and became widespread leading to the imposition of President’s rule in the state.… Gujarat and Bihar movements … In March 1974 students came together in Bihar to protest against rising prices, food scarcity, unemployment and corruption.… Declaration of Emergency On 12 June 1975, Justice Jagmohan Lal Sinha of the Allahabad High Court passed a judgment declaring Indira Gandhi’s election to the Lok Sabha invalid.… Exercises … The Shah Commission was appointed in 1977 by the Janata Party Government. Why was it appointed and what were its findings?…” |