Harappan artefacts were found fairly often in the nineteenth century and some reached Cunningham, yet a site like Harappa did not fit his framework of investigation. What explains this?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → It was neither on the Chinese pilgrims' itinerary nor an Early Historic city.
Option (1) Its seals had already been dated through finds at Mesopotamian sites. — Does not explain it. The seal finds at Mesopotamian sites came only in the 1920s, long after Cunningham. They later showed that the Harappan civilisation was as old as Mesopotamia, so they cannot explain his confusion.
Option (2) Its mound had been dug in horizontal units, ignoring stratigraphy. — Does not explain it. Digging in horizontal units while ignoring stratigraphy was John Marshall's method. It belongs to a later Director-General, not to Cunningham's way of working.
Option (3) It was neither on the Chinese pilgrims' itinerary nor an Early Historic city. — Explains it. Cunningham used the accounts of Chinese Buddhist pilgrims to find early settlements, and his interest was the Early Historic period. Harappa was neither on the pilgrims' route nor known as an Early Historic city, so it fell outside his framework.
Option (4) It had been identified as a Late Harappan site in decline. — Does not explain it. Cunningham did not know how old Harappan objects were at all. He believed Indian history began with the first cities of the Ganga valley, so he never placed Harappa in any Harappan phase.
NCERT (2026-27): “10.1 Cunningham’s confusion “A site like Harappa, which was not part of the itinerary of the Chinese pilgrims and was not known as an Early Historic city, did not fit very neatly within his framework of investigation. So, although Harappan artefacts were found fairly often during the nineteenth century and some of these reached Cunningham, he did not realise how old these were. A Harappan seal was given to Cunningham by an Englishman. He noted the object, but unsuccessfully tried to place it within the time-frame with which he was familiar. This was because he, like many others, thought that Indian history began with the first cities in the Ganga valley (see Chapter 2). Given his specific focus, it is not surprising that he missed the significance of Harappa.” |