Which among the following statement is not true about the Mandal Commission?
A. It was officially known as Second Backward Class Commission.
B. The Commission gave its recommendations in 1980.
C. It recommended reserving 30 percent of seats in educational institutes and Government jobs.
D. The decision was challenged in Supreme Court known as 'Keshvanand Bharti Case'.
E. National front decided to implement one of the recommendations of Mandal Commission.
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 4
The correct answer is Option (4) → C, D only
A. It was officially known as Second Backward Class Commission. True. The Commission appointed in 1978 was the second such commission since Independence, so it was officially known as the Second Backward Classes Commission; popularly it is called the Mandal Commission.
B. The Commission gave its recommendations in 1980. True. By then the Janata government had fallen.
C. It recommended reserving 30 percent of seats in educational institutes and Government jobs. False. It recommended reserving 27 per cent of seats in educational institutions and government jobs for the backward castes.
D. The decision was challenged in Supreme Court known as ‘Keshvanand Bharti Case’. False. The decision to implement the recommendation was challenged in the Supreme Court as the ‘Indira Sawhney case’, after the name of one of the petitioners. In November 1992 the Court upheld the decision.
E. National front decided to implement one of the recommendations of Mandal Commission. True. In August 1990 the National Front government decided to implement the recommendation on reservations for OBCs in jobs in the central government and its undertakings.
NCERT (2026-27): “The Mandal Commission … Following this, the central government appointed a Commission in 1978 to look into and recommend ways to improve the conditions of the backward classes. This was the second time since Independence that the government had appointed such a commission. Therefore, this commission was officially known as the Second Backward Classes Commission.… The Mandal Commission … The Commission gave its recommendations in 1980. By then the Janata government had fallen. The Commission advised that ‘backward classes’ should be understood to mean ‘backward castes’, since many castes, other than the Scheduled Castes, were also treated as low in the caste hierarchy. The Commission did a survey and found that these backward castes had a very low presence in both educational institutions and in employment in public services. It therefore recommended reserving 27 per cent of seats in educational institutions and government jobs for these groups. The Mandal Commission also made many other recommendations, like, land reform, to improve the conditions of the OBCs. In August 1990, the National Front government decided to implement one of the recommendations of Mandal Commission pertaining to reservations for OBCs in jobs in the central government and its undertakings. This decision sparked agitations and violent protests in many cities of north India. The decision was also challenged in the Supreme Court and came to be known as the ‘Indira Sawhney case’, after the name of one of the petitioners. In November 1992, the Supreme Court gave a ruling upholding the decision of the government.…” |