Select the option that best expresses the sentence in Indirect Speech.
The father said to his son, "Why were you crying yesterday?"
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 1
The correct answer is Option (1) → The father asked his son why he had been crying the previous day.
Direct to indirect speech (question):
| Change | Direct | Indirect | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reporting verb | said to his son | asked his son | A question is reported with “asked”: “said to his son” becomes “asked his son”. |
| Joining word | “ ” | why | The question word “why” itself joins the clauses. No “that”. |
| Word order | were you crying | he had been crying | The question becomes a statement: subject + verb. |
| Pronoun change | you | he | “You” becomes “he”. |
| Tense change | were crying | had been crying | Past continuous “were crying” becomes past perfect continuous “had been crying”. |
| Words of nearness (time and place) | yesterday | the previous day | “Yesterday” becomes “the previous day”. |
| Full sentence | The father said to his son, “Why were you crying yesterday?” | The father asked his son why he had been crying the previous day. |
Why the Other Options are Incorrect?
Option 2: The father asked his son that why he was crying the previous day. — Incorrect.
- "That" is not used with a question word like "why".
- The tense is not changed: "was crying" should be "had been crying".
Option 3: The father informed his son why he was crying the last day. — Incorrect.
- "Informed" turns a question into a statement of information.
- "The last day" is not the indirect form of "yesterday". The tense is also unchanged.
Option 4: The father asked his son why had been he crying the previous day. — Incorrect. It keeps the question word order (had been he). Indirect speech needs "he had been".