Read the following passage and answer the question.
Master Industries developed a new product, ‘Memory Sharpen Kit’, for kids. Mr. Shankar, the sales manager of the company, was asked to achieve target sales of 1000 kits in one month. He designed a sales plan for the kit without consulting his sales staff. He even refused to hear their suggestions and asked them to just follow his instructions. It led to frustration among the sales staff and, as a result, the sales target was not achieved on time. However, he made sure that every salesperson took orders from him alone and not from the other managers. He expects his colleagues to get work out of subordinates and yet has a differential treatment for each person. Mr. Shankar often bypasses the formal levels of authority and sends messages directly to junior staff, even when there is no emergency.
According to Fayol, which of the following would Mr. Shankar gain if he gave up his differential treatment of each person?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 2
The correct answer is Option (2) → Loyalty and devotion of employees
| Option | Reason |
|---|---|
| Option (1) Lower recruitment, selection and training cost. Incorrect. | Lower recruitment, selection and training cost comes from stability of personnel, because staff who stay need not be replaced; giving up differential treatment makes Mr. Shankar fair but keeps no one at a post, so this is not his gain. |
| Option (2) Loyalty and devotion of employees. Correct. | Giving up differential treatment means following equity, which asks for kindliness and justice towards workers; Fayol says this will ensure loyalty and devotion, so this is what Mr. Shankar would gain. |
| Option (3) Unity of action and coordination. Incorrect. | Unity of action and coordination come from unity of direction, because each group of activities then has one head and one plan; treating each person fairly creates no single plan, so this is not his gain. |
| Option (4) More and better work through specialisation. Incorrect. | More and better work through specialisation comes from division of work, because a trained specialist does each job; giving up differential treatment makes Mr. Shankar fair but divides no work, so this is not his gain. |
NCERT Extract (2026-27 Edition): Correct option (2) (xi) Equity: “This principle emphasises kindliness and justice in the behaviour of managers towards workers. This will ensure loyalty and devotion. … There should be no discrimination against anyone on account of gender, religion, language, caste, belief or nationality etc.” Wrong options (1), (3) and (4) (xii) Stability of Personnel: “They would tend to leave the organisation. Recruitment, selection and training cost will be high.” (v) Unity of Direction: “Each group of activities having the same objective must have one head and one plan. This ensures unity of action and coordination.” (i) Division of Work: “Work is divided into small tasks/ jobs. A trained specialist who is competent is required to perform each job. Thus, division of work leads to specialisation.” |