Many historians remain sceptical of oral history and dismiss it because of which reason?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → Uniqueness of personal experience makes generalisation difficult.
Option (1) It broadens the boundaries of their discipline. — Incorrect. This is a strength of oral history, not a reason for doubting it: it allows historians to broaden the boundaries of their discipline by rescuing the lived experiences of the poor and the powerless.
Option (2) It enables historians to write vivid accounts of what happened. — Incorrect. This too is a strength: personal reminiscence helps historians write richly textured, vivid accounts of what happened to people during events such as Partition.
Option (3) Uniqueness of personal experience makes generalisation difficult. — Correct. Sceptical historians argue that the uniqueness of personal experience makes generalisation difficult: a large picture cannot be built from such micro-evidence, and one witness is no witness. They also say oral data lack concreteness and give an imprecise chronology.
Option (4) It has explored the experience of those men and women whose existence has been ignored. — Incorrect. This is what oral history has achieved: the oral history of Partition has explored the experiences of men and women whose existence had been ignored in mainstream history.
Note: This question is taken from the chapter ‘Understanding Partition’ which was there in the pre-rationalised NCERT and has been deleted from subsequent editions of NCERT, including the NCERT book (2026-27).
NCERT (Pre-rationalised): “5.2 Preserving ‘honour’ … One of the strengths of personal reminiscence – one type of oral source – is that it helps us grasp experiences and memories in detail. It enables historians to write richly textured, vivid accounts of what happened to people during events such as Partition.… 5.2 Preserving ‘honour’ … Oral history also allows historians to broaden the boundaries of their discipline by rescuing from oblivion the lived experiences of the poor and the powerless… 5.2 Preserving ‘honour’ … Thus, moving beyond the actions of the well off and the well known, the oral history of Partition has succeeded in exploring the experiences of those men and women whose existence has hitherto been ignored, taken for granted, or mentioned only in passing in mainstream history. This is significant because the histories that we read often regard the life and work of the mass of the people in the past as inaccessible or unimportant.… 5.2 Preserving ‘honour’ … Yet, many historians still remain sceptical of oral history. They dismiss it because oral data seem to lack concreteness and the chronology they yield may be imprecise. Historians argue that the uniqueness of personal experience makes generalisation difficult: a large picture cannot be built from such micro-evidence, and one witness is no witness. They also think oral accounts are concerned with tangential issues, and that the small individual experiences which remain in memory are irrelevant to the unfolding of larger processes of history.…” |