If Penny is the mother of the daughter of Charlie's brother, then how is Penny related to Charlie?

Brother's wife

ATQ,

*********************************************************

Please note:

  l   ⇒ Vertical line shown "generation gap".

 =  ⇒ Double lines shown "relation of spouse" 

—  ⇒ Horizontal line shown "relation in same generation other than spouse".

     ⇒ Rectangular box shown " Male".

     ⇒ Circular box shown " Female".

*********************************************************