Choose the most appropriate reported construction of the following sentence :
She said to me, "Can you answer this question?" "No", I said.
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → She asked me if I could answer that question. I replied that I couldn't.
Yes/no question and a short reply in indirect speech:
Other standard changes: do/does → did, will → would, may → might, is/am → was, has/have → had.
| Change | Direct | Indirect | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reporting verb | said to ... said | asked ... replied | “Said to” becomes asked for the question. “Said” becomes replied for the answer. |
| Joining word | “ ” (inverted commas) | if ... that | The question is joined with if (or whether) and statement word order. The answer is joined with that. |
| Tense change | can | could | The reporting verb is in the past, so “can” becomes could. |
| Short reply | No | I couldn't | The short reply “No” becomes the full negative “I couldn't”. |
| Pronoun change | you | I | “You” (the listener, “me”) becomes I. |
| Words of nearness | this | that | “This” becomes that. |
| Full sentence | She said to me, “Can you answer this question?” “No”, I said. | She asked me if I could answer that question. I replied that I couldn't. |
Example: He said to me, “Can you swim?” → He asked me if I could swim.
Why the Other Options are Incorrect?
Option 1: She asked me if I can answer that question. I said, I couldn't. — Incorrect.
- "can" is not moved back to "could".
- "I said, I couldn't" leaves the reply half in direct speech.
Option 2: She asked me if I could answer that question. I said, I can't. — Incorrect. The reply is left in direct form, and "can't" is not moved back to "couldn't".
Option 4: She asked me if I could answer this question. I replied in affirmation. — Incorrect.
- "this" is not changed to "that".
- "Replied in affirmation" means the answer was yes, but it was "No".
Contrast: in indirect speech "can" moves back to could and the reply is reported with "replied that". "I said, I can't" leaves the reply in direct speech.