"A sales manager has to negotiate a deal with a buyer. She finds that if she can offer a credit period of 60 days, she is likely to clinch the deal which is supposed to fetch the company a net margin of say Rs. 50 crores. The company entrusts her the task of clinching the deal but gives her power to offer a credit period of only 40 days". Identify the principle of management violated in the aforesaid statement.
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 1
The correct answer is Option (1) → Authority and Responsibility
Option (1) Authority and Responsibility — Correct. Authority is the right to give orders and get them obeyed. Responsibility is the duty to complete the job. Fayol said there should be a balance between the two. Here the manager is responsible for clinching the deal. The deal needs a credit period of 60 days. But she has authority to offer only 40 days. Her authority is less than her responsibility, so the balance is broken.
Option (2) Unity of Command — Incorrect. This principle says that an employee should get orders from only one boss. Here the manager gets orders from one source only. There are no two bosses giving different orders.
Option (3) Unity of Direction — Incorrect. This principle says that each group of activities with the same objective should have one head and one plan. The case is not about how departments or divisions are set up.
Option (4) Scalar Chain — Incorrect. The scalar chain is the formal line of authority from the highest rank to the lowest. The case is not about the route through which orders or messages travel.
NCERT (2026-27 Edition): “Authority and Responsibility: According to Fayol, “Authority is the right to give orders and obtain obedience, and responsibility is the corollary of authority. The two types of authority are official authority, which is the authority to command, and personal authority which is the authority of the individual manager.” Authority is both formal and informal. Managers require authority commensurate with their responsibility. There should be a balance between authority and responsibility. An organisation should build safeguards against abuse of managerial power. At the same time a manager should have necessary authority to carry out his responsibility. …” “…Now the company gives power to the manager to offer a credit period of only 40 days. This shows that there is an imbalance in authority and responsibility. …” |