A company can increase the earnings per share by increasing the debt component in the capital structure.
Which condition is required for justifying this statement?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 1
The correct answer is Option (1) → Return on Investment > Cost of Debt
Option (1) Return on Investment > Cost of Debt — Correct. Using more cheap debt to raise EPS (earnings per share) is called trading on equity. It works only when the firm earns more on its money (RoI) than it pays as interest. The extra earning goes to the equity shareholders, so EPS goes up. In the example the RoI is 13.33% and interest is 10%, so more debt raises the EPS.
Option (2) Return on Investment < Cost of Debt — Incorrect. Here the firm earns less than it pays as interest. More debt then reduces the EPS. The second example (RoI 6.67%, interest 10%) shows this. It is called unfavourable financial leverage.
Option (3) Return on Investment = Cost of Debt — Incorrect. The borrowed money earns just enough to pay its own interest. Nothing extra is left for shareholders, so EPS does not rise.
Option (4) Do not consider Return of Investment and Cost of Debt — Incorrect. Comparing RoI with the cost of debt is the very test. RoI is an important factor in deciding whether a company can use trading on equity.
NCERT (2026-27 Edition): “EBIT-EPS Analysis … The company earns Rs. 0.93 per share if it is unlevered. With debt of Rs. 10 lakh its EPS is Rs. 1.05. With a still higher debt of Rs. 20 lakh, its, EPS rises to Rs. 1.40. Why is the EPS rising with higher debt? It is because the cost of debt is lower than the return that company is earning on funds employed. …” “…This is higher than the 10% interest it is paying on debt funds. With higher use of debt, this difference between RoI and cost of debt increases the EPS. This is a situation of favourable financial leverage. In such cases, companies often employ more of cheaper debt to enhance the EPS. Such practice is called Trading on Equity.” “In this example, the EPS of the company is falling with increased use of debt. It is because the Company’s rate of return on investment (RoI) is less than the cost of debt. …” “Return on Investment (RoI): If the RoI of the company is higher, it can choose to use trading on equity to increase its EPS, i.e., its ability to use debt is greater. …” |