Three teachers rated 40 students on a 5-point scale of punctuality. Which bias is shown by Ms Gill?
| Teacher | How she rated |
|---|---|
| Ms Rao | Almost every student 1 or 5 |
| Ms Gill | Almost every student 3 |
| Ms Das | High on every trait for his politeness |
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → Middle category bias
| Option | Reason |
|---|---|
| Option (1): Halo effect. Incorrect. | Halo effect is when a single favourable or unfavourable trait, such as politeness, shapes the rater's whole judgment of a person. |
| Option (2): Extreme response bias. Incorrect. | Extreme response bias places individuals in the extreme positions of the scale, avoiding the middle categories. |
| Option (3): Middle category bias. Correct. | Middle category bias is placing individuals in the middle of the scale by avoiding extreme positions, which is the pattern of giving almost everyone a 3. |
| Option (4): Personal bias. Incorrect. | Personal bias is a rater's own liking or dislike for one particular person, which colours the rating given to that person. |
NCERT (2026-27): “Behavioural Ratings … “(1) Raters often display certain biases that colour their judgments of different traits. For example, most of us are greatly influenced by a single favourable or unfavourable trait. This often forms the basis of a rater’s overall judgment of a person. This tendency is known as the halo effect.” “(2) Raters have a tendency to place individuals either in the middle of the scale (called middle category bias) by avoiding extreme positions, or in the extreme positions (called extreme response bias) by avoiding middle categories on the scale.” |