Read the following passage and answer the question.
Mr. Raju is the factory manager of M/s Playing Kids Pvt. Ltd., a toy manufacturing company. In order to ensure unity of command, Mr. Raju appointed just one foreman, Mr. Surya, for the entire production planning, implementation and control of the workmen. However, Surya was not competent enough to supervise both planning and execution. This reduced the quality of work and the efficiency of the workmen. Mr. Raju also expects his subordinates to adapt to a new environment and new working conditions without giving them time to settle down. A good practice in the company is that every piece of equipment, and even every person, has a prescribed place. Mr. Raju gave his subordinate the duty of collecting samples of toys from the office, but the subordinate could not do the task, as only superiors and top executives were allowed to enter the office.
Which of the following statements about Mr. Raju’s decision about Surya is correct?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 1
The correct answer is Option (1) → It goes against functional foremanship, which is an extension of the principle of division of work to the shop floor.
| Option | Reason |
|---|---|
| Option (1) It goes against functional foremanship, which is an extension of the principle of division of work to the shop floor. Correct. | Taylor suggested functional foremanship through eight persons because no single person could fit all the qualities of a good foreman; Mr. Raju gave the whole work to Surya alone, so he goes against it, and it extends division of work. |
| Option (2) It goes against functional foremanship, which is an extension of the principle of unity of command to the shop floor. Incorrect. | Functional foremanship is an extension of division of work and specialisation, not of unity of command, so this statement names the wrong principle. |
| Option (3) It follows functional foremanship, which is an extension of the principle of division of work to the shop floor. Incorrect. | Functional foremanship rests on separation of planning and execution among several persons; giving both to one person is the reverse of this, so the decision does not follow it. |
| Option (4) It follows functional foremanship, which is an extension of the principle of unity of command to the shop floor. Incorrect. | Functional foremanship needs several specialists, so giving all the work to one person does not follow it; and the technique extends division of work, not unity of command, so both parts are wrong. |
NCERT Extract (2026-27 Edition): Correct option (1) Functional Foremanship: “Functional foremanship is an extension of the principle of division of work and specialisation to the shop floor.” “In fact, he identified a list of qualities of a good foreman/supervisor and found that no single person could fit them all. This prompted him to suggest functional foremanship through eight persons.” Wrong options (3) and (4) Functional Foremanship: “Taylor advocated separation of planning and execution functions. This concept was extended to the lowest level of the shop floor.” |