Why did some scholars argue that the state should get out of areas which the private sector can manage?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 1
The correct answer is Option (1) → The government continued to run activities, such as hotels, which the private sector could also manage well.
No line was drawn between what only the public sector can do and what the private sector can also do. The government even ran hotels.
Option (1) The government continued to run activities, such as hotels, which the private sector could also manage well. — Correct. So scholars said the state should leave such areas and use its resources for services the private sector cannot provide.
Option (2) The private sector could supply national defence better than the government. — Incorrect. National defence is an example of what only the public sector supplies.
Option (3) Public sector firms had to obtain licenses before expanding output. — Incorrect. Licenses to expand controlled private industry.
Option (4) Small-scale industries could not compete with public sector firms. — Incorrect. Small units needed shielding from big firms in general. This says nothing about the state’s role.
NCERT (2026-27): “2.5 Trade Policy: Import Substitution … The point is that after four decades of Planned development of Indian Economy no distinction was made between (i) what the public sector alone can do and (ii) what the private sector can also do. For example, even now only the public sector supplies national defense. And even though the private sector can manage hotels well, yet, the government also runs hotels. This has led some scholars to argue that the state should get out of areas which the private sector can manage and the government may concentrate its resources on important services which the private sector cannot provide. …” |