Sita and Geeta are two close friends and both are graduate working women. Sita is an economics graduate and doing research in economics while Geeta is a customer relation manager in a multinational company. On 1st January, 2023 both the friends decide to go out for a dinner to celebrate new year. Geeta is fond of Ice-Cream (Orange bar) and has decided to buy it from a street vendor at ₹10/unit after discount. She has also offered it to Sita but Sita refused as she was having a throat infection.
Geeta has requested Sita to apply economics principles and to tell her when she should stop consuming more ice-cream. On consuming the 3rd unit of Ice-cream, Geeta has obtained additional satisfaction of 18 utils while the marginal utility of a rupee is 2 utils.
Suppose that you are Sita. Being a good friend of Geeta, you are required to suggest whether Geeta should stop or consume more units of ice-cream. (Identify the correct option.)
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → Geeta is in deficit, hence she should not consume more units of ice-cream.
At ₹10, the 3rd ice-cream is worth less to Geeta than its price. So Sita should advise her to stop.
Given:
Marginal utility of the 3rd unit, MU = 18 utils
Marginal utility of a rupee = 2 utils
Price, P = ₹10
The rupee value of a unit is its marginal utility divided by the marginal utility of a rupee.
MU in rupees = 18 ÷ 2 = ₹9
₹9 < ₹10, so MU in rupees is less than the price.
The 3rd unit gives her ₹9 worth of satisfaction but costs ₹10. This loss of ₹1 is her deficit. By the law of diminishing marginal utility, a 4th unit would give even less, so the loss would grow. She would be in equilibrium only if the unit were worth just ₹10. The passage gives every figure needed to decide.