Choose the correct transformation of the given sentence in Indirect Speech:
Mrs Sharma said to the gardener, “Will you water my plants while I am in Goa?”
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 4
The correct answer is Option (4) → Mrs Sharma asked the gardener if he would water her plants while she was in Goa.
Changing a yes/no question into indirect speech:
| Change | Direct | Indirect | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reporting verb | said to the gardener | asked the gardener | Mrs Sharma puts a question. So “said to” becomes “asked”. |
| Joining word | “ ” (quotation marks) | if | The question is answered with yes or no. So “if” (or “whether”) joins it. |
| Word order | Will you water | he would water | The question order changes to the plain order. The subject “he” comes before “would”, and the question mark goes. |
| Pronoun change | you, my, I | he, her, she | The gardener is spoken to, so “you” becomes “he”. Mrs Sharma is the speaker, so “my” becomes “her” and “I” becomes “she”. |
| Tense change | will, am | would, was | After the past “said”, “will” becomes “would” (would + base form (V1)). The simple present “am” becomes the simple past “was”. The verb “be” in the simple present is am / is / are. The verb “be” in the simple past is was / were. |
| Full sentence | Mrs Sharma said to the gardener, “Will you water my plants while I am in Goa?” | Mrs Sharma asked the gardener if he would water her plants while she was in Goa. |
“Can” in a question becomes “could” in the same way. Example: Raj said to me, “Can you swim?” → Raj asked me if I could swim.
Why the Other Options are Incorrect?
Option 1: Mrs Sharma asked the gardener if he will water her plants while she was in Goa. — Incorrect. “Will” is kept. After the past “said” it must become “would”.
Option 2: Mrs Sharma asked the gardener if would he water her plants while she was in Goa. — Incorrect. “Would he” keeps the question word order. In a reported question the subject comes first: “he would”.
Option 3: Mrs Sharma asked the gardener that he would water her plants while she was in Goa. — Incorrect. “That” joins a statement. A yes/no question is joined with “if” or “whether”.