If \(\vec{x}\) and \(\vec{y}\) are two collinear vectors, then which of the following are incorrect?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 4
The correct answer is Option (4) → the respective components of \(\vec{x}\) and \(\vec{y}\) are not proportional
Note: The given answer is as per the official NTA Answer Key. However, more than one answer is possible: Option (1), Option (3) and Option (4) are all correct, as explained below.
Two vectors are collinear when they lie along the same line or parallel lines, that is, when one is a scalar multiple of the other:
\(\vec{y} = \lambda\vec{x}\) for some scalar \(\lambda\)
With \(\vec{x} = a_1\hat{\imath} + b_1\hat{\jmath} + c_1\hat{k}\) and \(\vec{y} = a_2\hat{\imath} + b_2\hat{\jmath} + c_2\hat{k}\), this means the components are proportional:
\( \displaystyle \frac{a_2}{a_1} = \frac{b_2}{b_1} = \frac{c_2}{c_1} = \lambda \)
The scalar \(\lambda\) may be positive (same direction) or negative (opposite directions), and \(|\lambda|\) may or may not be 1 (equal or different lengths). The question asks for the statements that are not true for collinear vectors.
Option (1) \(\vec{x}=\pm\vec{y}\) — Should also be correct, though not the answer given by NTA. This holds only when the two vectors have the same length. For example, \(\vec{y} = 2\vec{x}\) is collinear with \(\vec{x}\), but \(\vec{x}\) is neither \(\vec{y}\) nor \(-\vec{y}\). So the statement is not true for collinear vectors in general.
Option (2) \(\vec{y}=\lambda\vec{x}\), for some scalar \(\lambda\) — Incorrect. This is exactly the condition for two vectors to be collinear, so the statement is true and is not an answer.
Option (3) Both the vectors \(\vec{x}\) and \(\vec{y}\) have same direction, but different magnitudes. — Should also be correct, though not the answer given by NTA. Collinear vectors may point in opposite directions (\(\vec{y} = -2\vec{x}\)) or have equal lengths (\(\vec{y} = \vec{x}\)). So the statement is not true for collinear vectors in general.
Option (4) the respective components of \(\vec{x}\) and \(\vec{y}\) are not proportional — Correct. The components of collinear vectors are always proportional, with ratio \(\lambda\), so this statement is false for every pair of collinear vectors.
Advice for the exam: When more than one option is correct, mark the one that fits the question in every case, here Option (4), the only statement that is false for every pair of collinear vectors. If NTA’s provisional answer key marks a different option, challenge it during the answer-key challenge window, giving proper reasoning. NTA does revise its key when a challenge is well justified, so a sound challenge can raise your marks.