A mobile company offers two monthly plans. Plan P has a fixed charge of Rs. 200 plus Rs. 1 per minute of calls. Plan Q has a fixed charge of Rs. 50 plus Rs. 2.50 per minute of calls. If \(x\) is the number of minutes of calls in a month, Plan P is cheaper than Plan Q exactly when
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 4
The correct answer is Option (4) → \(x \gt 100\)
The monthly bill for \(x\) minutes is \(200 + x\) rupees in Plan P and \(50 + 2.5x\) rupees in Plan Q. Plan P is cheaper when its bill is less than the bill of Plan Q.
\(200 + x \lt 50 + 2.5x\)
\(150 \lt 1.5x\)
\(x \gt 100\)
Check: at 100 minutes both bills are Rs. 300; at 120 minutes Plan P costs Rs. 320 and Plan Q costs Rs. 350. So Plan P is cheaper for more than 100 minutes.
Why the other options are incorrect
Option (1) \(x \lt 100\) — Incorrect. For fewer than 100 minutes Plan Q is cheaper; for example, at 40 minutes P costs Rs. 240 and Q costs Rs. 150.
Option (2) \(x \gt 60\) — Incorrect. This divides 150 by 2.5 instead of by the difference \(2.5 - 1 = 1.5\); at 80 minutes P costs Rs. 280 and Q costs Rs. 250.
Option (3) \(x \lt 60\) — Incorrect. For fewer than 60 minutes Plan Q is the cheaper plan, since its fixed charge is Rs. 150 less.