Which technique of Scientific Management violates Fayol's principle of Equity?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → Differential Piece Wage System
Option (1) Standardization of work — Incorrect. Standardisation sets standard tools, methods and materials for every worker. It applies the same rules to all, so it does not go against equity.
Option (2) Motion Study — Incorrect. Motion study removes needless movements from a job. It does not treat any worker unfairly.
Option (3) Differential Piece Wage System — Correct. Taylor’s differential piece wage system pays a higher rate to workers who reach the standard output and a lower rate to those who do not. Two workers doing the same job get different pay. This clashes with Fayol’s principle of equity, which asks for fair and equal treatment of all employees.
Option (4) Mental Revolution — Incorrect. Mental revolution means a change of attitude so that workers and management cooperate. It supports harmony, not unfair treatment.
NCERT (2026-27 Edition): “Differential Piece Wage System Taylor was a strong advocate of piece wage system. He wanted to differentiate between efficient and inefficient workers. The standard time and other parameters should be determined on the basis of the work-study discussed above. The workers can then be classified as efficient or inefficient on the basis of these standards. He wanted to reward efficient workers. So he introduced different rate of wage payment for those who performed above standard and for those who performed below standard. …” “(xi) Equity: Good sense and experience are needed to ensure fairness to all employees, who should be treated as fairly as possible,” according to Fayol. This principle emphasises kindliness and justice in the behaviour of managers towards workers. …” |