Which of the following is incorrect in the context of Fundamental Rights?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 2
The correct answer is Option 2: The terse words of Article 19 recognising the right to life and liberty have been interpreted as including all that goes into a life of quality, including livelihood, health, shelter, education and dignity.
Option 1 — “A Fundamental Right includes all that is incidental to it.” — True. A Fundamental Right is not restricted only to its literal wording. It can include rights and protections that are incidental or necessary for giving meaningful effect to that Fundamental Right.
Option 2 — “The terse words of Article 19 recognising the right to life and liberty have been interpreted as including all that goes into a life of quality, including livelihood, health, shelter, education and dignity.” — False. The error is the reference to Article 19. The right to life and liberty is guaranteed under Article 21, not Article 19. Article 21 has been interpreted to include aspects necessary for a life of quality, such as livelihood, health, shelter, education and dignity.
Option 3 — “In various judicial pronouncements, different attributes of ‘life’ have been expanded and ‘life’ has been explained to mean more than mere animal existence.” — True. The meaning of ‘life’ under Article 21 has been given a broad interpretation. It is not confined to mere physical existence but includes various conditions necessary for a life of quality and dignity.
Option 4 — “In 1993 the Supreme Court held that Right to Information is a part of and incidental to the Right to Freedom of Speech and Expression under Article 19(1) (a).” — True. The Right to Information was recognised as being part of and incidental to the Right to Freedom of Speech and Expression under Article 19(1)(a). This interpretation expanded the practical scope of the Fundamental Right.
NCERT: "A Fundamental Right includes all that is incidental to it. The terse words of Article 21 recognising the right to life and liberty have been interpreted as including all that goes into a life of quality, including livelihood, health, shelter, education and dignity. In various pronouncements, different attributes of ‘life’ have been expanded and ‘life’ has been explained to mean more than mere animal existence. These interpretations have been used to provide relief to prisoners subjected to torture and deprivation, release and rehabilitation of bonded labourers, against environmentally degrading activities, to provide primary healthcare and primary education. In 1993 the Supreme Court held that Right to Information is a part of and incidental to the Right to Freedom of Speech and Expression under Article 19(1) (a). "