Ms. Kulkarni, a school counsellor in Pune, is selecting students for a special programme. She gives one test in which students examine an incomplete pattern of figures and choose the figure that completes it. She also collects teachers' judgment, school records and parents' interviews. Aarav's parents recall that as a toddler he noticed at once when a single picture on the wall had been moved, and that he pushed aside toys he had played with before to reach for ones he had never seen. Simran, a state-level sprinter, has average marks. The principal says only marks and test scores should decide who is gifted. Ms. Kulkarni plans a programme, beyond regular classroom teaching, for the students selected.
Which of the following best evaluates the principal's view in Simran's case?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 2
The correct answer is Option (4) → It is incorrect, since athletes who show superior psychomotor ability are also gifted.
| Option | Reason |
|---|---|
| Option (1): It is correct, since giftedness is shown in brilliant academic performance. Incorrect. | Giftedness is exceptional general ability shown in superior performance in a wide variety of areas. To equate it with brilliant academic performance is incorrect. |
| Option (2): It is incorrect, since Simran shows talent, which means the same as giftedness. Incorrect. | Talent is a narrower term and means remarkable ability in a specific field. Giftedness is exceptional general ability across many areas. |
| Option (3): It is correct, since performance on intelligence tests is the main measure of the gifted. Incorrect. | Teachers' judgment, school achievement records, parents' interviews and peer and self-ratings are used along with intellectual assessment to identify the gifted. |
| Option (4): It is incorrect, since athletes who show superior psychomotor ability are also gifted. Correct. | Gifted children show early signs of intellectual superiority, and athletes who show superior psychomotor ability are also gifted. So strong sporting ability with average marks can still mark a gifted student. |
NCERT (2026-27): “Intellectual Giftedness … “Performance on intelligence tests is not the only measure for identifying the gifted. Many other sources of information, such as teachers’ judgment, school achievement record, parents’ interviews, peer and selfratings, etc. can be used in combination with intellectual assessment. …” |