Read the following passage and answer the question.
Mr. Mehta bought a bottle of water from Zaika Bazaar, a restaurant in Karkardooma Complex, Delhi. He read the label on the bottle, which showed a maximum retail price (MRP) of ₹18, but he was asked to pay ₹38 for it. He filed a complaint, and the District Commission directed the restaurant owner to pay him a compensation of ₹15,000 for overcharging. The Commission said that no trader or service provider can charge more than the MRP printed on a packed item. It also ordered the restaurant owner to discontinue the malpractice. The order came at a time when consumer courts are acting strictly against shop-owners who overcharge. In an earlier case, a consumer commission had fined a cineplex ₹50,000 for a similar malpractice.
Read the following statements and choose the correct option.
Assertion (A): The restaurant owner can appeal against the order in Mr. Mehta’s case directly to the National Commission.
Reason (R): A party not satisfied with the order of a District Commission can appeal to the State Commission within forty-five days.
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 4
The correct answer is Option (4) → (A) is false but (R) is true.
Assertion (A): The restaurant owner can appeal against the order in Mr. Mehta’s case directly to the National Commission. — False. The case was decided by the District Commission. An appeal against a District Commission’s order goes to the State Commission. Only an order of the State Commission can be taken to the National Commission.
Reason (R): A party not satisfied with the order of a District Commission can appeal to the State Commission within forty-five days. — True. A party not satisfied with the District Commission’s order can appeal to the State Commission within forty-five days of the order.
NCERT (2026-27 Edition): “1. District Commission: … If any of the parties are not satisfied by the order of District Commission can appeal against such order to the State Commission on the grounds of facts or law within a period of forty five days from the date of order.” “2. State Commission: It is established by the respective state government and ordinarily function at the state capital. State Commission has a jurisdiction to entertain complaints where value of goods and services paid as consideration that exceeds rupees fifty lakh but does not exceed two crore. If any of the parties are not satisfied by the order of State Commission can appeal against such order to the National Commission within a period of thirty days of such order.” |