Consider the following statements about the first row (3d) transition metals and their ions.
(A) The general trend towards less negative E°(M2+/M) values across the series is related to the increase in the sum of the first and second ionisation enthalpies.
(B) Titanium and vanadium, in practice, are passive to dilute non-oxidising acids at room temperature.
(C) Mn3+ and Co3+ ions are the strongest reducing agents in aqueous solutions.
(D) The E° values for Mn, Ni and Zn are less negative than expected from the general trend.
(E) The ions Ti2+, V2+ and Cr2+ are strong reducing agents and liberate hydrogen from a dilute acid.
Which of the statements given above are incorrect? Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 2
The correct answer is Option (2) → (C) and (D) only
The E°(M2+/M) value shows how readily a metal forms its M2+ ion, and the E°(M3+/M2+) value shows how readily M3+ is reduced to M2+. A large positive E°(M3+/M2+) means a strong oxidising M3+ ion.
(A) The general trend towards less negative E°(M2+/M) values across the series is related to the increase in the sum of the first and second ionisation enthalpies. — Correct statement. As ΔiH1 + ΔiH2 rises, forming M2+ becomes harder, so E° becomes less negative.
(B) Titanium and vanadium, in practice, are passive to dilute non-oxidising acids at room temperature. — Correct statement. Their E° values allow them to be oxidised by H+, but the reaction is slow in practice.
(C) Mn3+ and Co3+ ions are the strongest reducing agents in aqueous solutions. — Incorrect statement. Their E°(M3+/M2+) values are the most positive in the series, so these ions readily gain an electron: they are the strongest oxidising agents.
(D) The E° values for Mn, Ni and Zn are less negative than expected from the general trend. — Incorrect statement. They are more negative than expected: the half-filled d5 of Mn2+ and the filled d10 of Zn2+ are stable, and Ni2+ has the most negative hydration enthalpy.
(E) The ions Ti2+, V2+ and Cr2+ are strong reducing agents and liberate hydrogen from a dilute acid. — Correct statement. For example:
\( \displaystyle \ce{2Cr^2+(aq) + 2H+(aq) -> 2Cr^3+(aq) + H2(g)} \)
NCERT (2026-27 edition):
4.3.8 Chemical Reactivity and E° Values – “The metals of the first series with the exception of copper are relatively more reactive and are oxidised by 1M H+, though the actual rate at which these metals react with oxidising agents like hydrogen ion (H+) is sometimes slow. For example, titanium and vanadium, in practice, are passive to dilute non oxidising acids at room temperature. The Eo values for M2+/M (Table 4.2) indicate a decreasing tendency to form divalent cations across the series. This general trend towards less negative Eo values is related to the increase in the sum of the first and second ionisation enthalpies. It is interesting to note that the Eo values for Mn, Ni and Zn are more negative than expected from the general trend. Whereas the stabilities of half-filled d subshell (d5) in Mn2+ and completely filled d subshell (d10) in zinc are related to their Eo values; for nickel, Eo value is related to the highest negative enthalpy of hydration.”
“An examination of the Eo values for the redox couple M3+/M2+ (Table 4.2) shows that Mn3+ and Co3+ ions are the strongest oxidising agents in aqueous solutions. The ions Ti2+, V2+ and Cr2+ are strong reducing agents and will liberate hydrogen from a dilute acid, e.g., 2 Cr2+(aq) + 2 H+(aq) → 2 Cr3+(aq) + H2(g)”