Each ether in List-I is heated with concentrated HI. Match List-I (ether and condition) with List-II (feature of its cleavage).
| List-I | List-II |
|---|---|
| (A) Methoxyethane, with 1 mol of HI | (I) The hydroxy compound formed first reacts with another molecule of HI to give a second iodide. |
| (B) 2-Methoxy-2-methylpropane | (II) Of the two alkyl groups, the lower alkyl group forms the alkyl iodide. |
| (C) Methoxybenzene (anisole) | (III) The reaction follows the SN1 mechanism through a stable carbocation. |
| (D) Ethoxyethane, with excess HI at high temperature | (IV) The O–alkyl bond breaks because the other C–O bond has partial double bond character. |
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 2
The correct answer is Option (2) → A-II, B-III, C-IV, D-I
Concentrated HI first protonates the ether oxygen. The iodide ion then breaks one C–O bond, giving an alkyl iodide and an alcohol (or phenol). Which bond breaks, and by which mechanism, depends on the groups on the oxygen.
(A) Methoxyethane, with 1 mol of HI — This matches (II) Of the two alkyl groups, the lower alkyl group forms the alkyl iodide. Both groups are primary, so I− attacks the less substituted methyl carbon by SN2:
\( \displaystyle \ce{CH3-O-C2H5 + HI -> CH3I + C2H5OH} \)
(B) 2-Methoxy-2-methylpropane — This matches (III) The reaction follows the SN1 mechanism through a stable carbocation. The leaving group (CH3OH) departs to give the stable tertiary carbocation, so the tertiary group, not the methyl group, ends up as the iodide:
\( \displaystyle \ce{(CH3)3C-O-CH3 + HI -> (CH3)3C-I + CH3OH} \)
(C) Methoxybenzene (anisole) — This matches (IV) The O–alkyl bond breaks because the other C–O bond has partial double bond character. The O–C6H5 bond is stronger (sp2 carbon, partial double bond), so the weaker O–CH3 bond breaks. The phenol formed does not react further, because its sp2 carbon cannot undergo nucleophilic substitution:
\( \displaystyle \ce{C6H5-O-CH3 + HI -> C6H5OH + CH3I} \)
(D) Ethoxyethane, with excess HI at high temperature — This matches (I) The hydroxy compound formed first reacts with another molecule of HI to give a second iodide. The ethanol formed in the first step is converted to ethyl iodide, so two molecules of ethyl iodide are obtained:
\( \displaystyle \ce{C2H5-O-C2H5 + HI -> C2H5I + C2H5OH} \)
\( \displaystyle \ce{C2H5OH + HI -> C2H5I + H2O} \)
NCERT (2026-27 edition):
7.6.3 Chemical Reactions – “…Thus, in the cleavage of mixed ethers with two different alkyl groups, the alcohol and alkyl iodide formed, depend on the nature of alkyl groups. When primary or secondary alkyl groups are present, it is the lower alkyl group that forms alkyl iodide (SN2 reaction).”
“However, when one of the alkyl group is a tertiary group, the halide formed is a tertiary halide.” … “It is because in step 2 of the reaction, the departure of leaving group (HO–CH3) creates a more stable carbocation [(CH3)3C+], and the reaction follows SN1 mechanism.”
“In case of anisole, methylphenyl oxonium ion, … is formed by protonation of ether. The bond between O–CH3 is weaker than the bond between O–C6H5 because the carbon of phenyl group is sp2 hybridised and there is a partial double bond character. Therefore the attack by I– ion breaks O–CH3 bond to form CH3I. Phenols do not react further to give halides because the sp2 hybridised carbon of phenol cannot undergo nucleophilic substitution reaction needed for conversion to the halide.”
“When HI is in excess and the reaction is carried out at high temperature, ethanol reacts with another molecule of HI and is converted to ethyl iodide.”