Meena and Ritu are both diligent, yet Meena shows it by making detailed notes and Ritu by practising past papers late into the night. Consider the following statements about how Allport would view this:
(A) Their behaviour shows that people sharing the same traits might express them in different ways.
(B) The way each reacts to the coming examination depends on her traits.
(C) The examination situation, not their traits, decides how each of them reacts.
(D) Diligence here is a cardinal trait around which each girl's entire life revolves.
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 4
The correct answer is Option (4) → A and B only
(A) Their behaviour shows that people sharing the same traits might express them in different ways. — Correct. Allport held that people who share a trait may express it in different ways. Meena and Ritu share diligence but show it through notes and past papers.
(B) The way each reacts to the coming examination depends on her traits. — Correct. For Allport, the way a person reacts to a given situation depends on her traits. Traits act as intervening variables between the situation and the response.
(C) The examination situation, not their traits, decides how each of them reacts. — Incorrect. The statement reverses Allport's position. He accepted that situations influence behaviour, yet held that the reaction depends on a person's traits: both girls face the same examination and still work in their own way.
(D) Diligence here is a cardinal trait around which each girl's entire life revolves. — Incorrect. Diligent is given as an example of a central trait, a generalised disposition of the kind used in a testimonial. The statement raises it to a life-dominating level, which making notes or practising papers before an examination does not show.
NCERT (2026-27): “Allport’s Trait Theory … “While Allport acknowledged the influence of situations on behaviour, he held that the way a person reacts to given situations depends on her/his traits, although people sharing the same traits might express them in different ways. …” |