CUETMOCK
  • Pricing
  • Mentors
Log inStart freeStart free mocks→

First test, then trust

Try a free CUET mock test.

Join 5,00,000+ students who rehearsed exam day on the exact NTA screen before sitting CUET. On the web and on Android.

Start free mocks →Get the Android app
CUETMOCK

India's #1 CUET Mock Test Platform. Original NCERT-based questions on the exact NTA exam screen — trusted by 5,00,000+ students since CUET 2022.

Get it onGoogle PlayScan to download the CUETMOCK app

Mock tests

  • CUET mock test series
  • Browse all papers
  • Commerce mocks
  • Humanities (Arts) mocks
  • Science mocks
  • Languages & GAT mocks
  • Free practice questions
  • Pricing

Resources

  • CUET exam guide
  • CUET syllabus
  • Universities accepting CUET
  • Expert blogs
  • News & notifications
  • Webinars & counselling
  • CUET score calculator
  • How we estimate your rank
  • FAQs

Company

  • About us
  • Our leadership & team
  • Our toppers
  • Mentors
  • For schools
  • Contact us
  • Terms
  • Privacy
  • Refund policy

Talk to us

+91 7696 6630 56info@cuetmock.comWhatsApp us

Our other platforms

  • JEE Mock — For IIT-JEE aspirants
  • NEET Mock — For NEET aspirants

Newsletter

Exam updates, study material and offers — no spam.

© 2026 NYC Ventures Pvt. Ltd.

701-702, Royal Business Park, Zirakpur, Punjab - 140603

  • Terms of use
  • Privacy policy
  • Refund policy
  • Contact us

iCUETMOCK is an independent preparation platform, not affiliated with the National Testing Agency (NTA). Always check exam details on the official NTA website.

  • Home
  • Mock tests
  • CUET guide
  • Pricing
  • Log in
Home/Practice questions/Legal Studies
Legal StudiesLegal Maxims

In Nihal Kaur v. Director, P.G.I., Chandigarh, 1996, scissors were le…

In Nihal Kaur v. Director, P.G.I., Chandigarh, 1996, scissors were left in the body of a patient during an operation. Then his condition worsened and he died. Scissors were recovered from the ashes after cremation. The relatives of the patients filed a case against the PGI for negligence. PGI contested the petition and argued that there was no negligence on its part. The recovery of the scissors was the circumstantial evidence which itself showed that an act has been committed. Therefore, a Compensation of Rs. 1,20,000 was awarded to the defendants of the deceased by the Court. The decision of the court was based on which legal maxim?
Answer & explanation+

Correct answer: option 1

Res ipsa loquitur: it means "the thing speaks for itself." In the law of torts, it is a very popular doctrine. In cases, where the evidence is itself sufficient to prove the guilt of the defendant, the maxim is used there. So, the maxim points out any circumstantial evidence or an object which itself shows that an act has been committed. It shows that if the defendant was not negligent, the accident would not have happened.
In the law of torts, to prove somebody's negligence, the burden of proof is on the plaintiff which means the person who is the victim of the tort. It becomes really difficult to prove that the defendant was at fault and also to gather evidence against his act or omission. If the plaintiff is not able to prove negligence on the part of the defendant, the defendant cannot be made liable. So, the principle of Res Ipsa Loquitor came into force under which a plaintiff can use circumstantial evidence to establish negligence.
In Nihal Kaur v. Director, P.G.I., Chandigarh, 1996, scissors were left in the body of a patient during an operation. Then his condition worsened and he died. Scissors were recovered from the ashes after cremation. Compensation of Rs. 1,20,000 was awarded to the defendants of the deceased.
In the case of Karnataka State Road Transport Corporation v. Krishnan, 1981, in an accident, the two buses brushed each other in such a way that the left hands of two passengers traveling in one of these buses were cut off below the shoulder joint. It was held that the accident itself speaks volumes about the negligence on the part of drivers of both vehicles. The doctrine of res ipsa loquitur was applied to the case and, in the absence of any satisfactory explanation, the defendants were held liable.

Advertisement

Practise more on Legal Maxims

Chapter-wise mocks on the real NTA exam screen, with solutions and your rank. Your first mocks are free.

Start free mocks →

Advertisement

Next questions

  1. The absolute permeability of a substance is less than that of free space. What can we say about it?Physics · Magnetism and Matter
  2. Cycas is an example of which of the following animal phylum?General Aptitude Test · General Knowledge
  3. In the figure, AB = AD = 7cm and AC = AE and BC = 11 cm, then find the length of ED.General Aptitude Test · Quantitative Reasoning
  4. Radius of first Bohr orbit is r. What is the radius of 2nd Bohr orbit?Physics · Atoms
  5. Which of the following statements is incorrect about the agricultural sector in India in the post-1991 reform period?Economics · Indian Economic Development: Liberalisation, Privatisation and Globalisation - An Appraisal
  6. If E is an electric field and B is the magnetic induction then the energy flow per unit area per unit time in an electromagnetic field is g…Physics · Electromagnetic Waves
  7. The marks obtained by three students P, Q and R in four subjects are written as the matrix A = […] , where the rows are for P, Q and R in t…Applied Maths. Section A · Matrices
  8. A value of p for which the points (1, 1, p) and (−3, 0, 1) are equidistant from the plane r·≤ft(3imath+4jmath-12k)+13=0 is:Maths. Section B1 · Three-dimensional Geometry
  9. Who among the following Indian musicians introduced shehnai to the concert stage and was selected to perform for the ceremony at Delhi’s hi…General Aptitude Test · General Knowledge
  10. How many faraday of charge is required to deposit 2 moles of Al^3+ from Al_2O_3 on cathodeChemistry · Physical: Electro Chemistry