Which of the following statements about the Constituent Assembly debate on the rights of the Centre and the states is NOT correct?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → Article 356 gave the Centre the powers to take over a state administration on the recommendation of the Chief Minister.
Option (1) One of the topics most vigorously debated in the Constituent Assembly was the respective rights of the Central Government and the states. — True. The rights of the Central Government and the states were among the topics most vigorously debated in the Assembly.
Option (2) Among those arguing for a strong Centre was Jawaharlal Nehru, as he put it in a letter to the President of the Constituent Assembly. — True. Nehru argued for a strong Centre in a letter to the President of the Assembly, saying a weak central authority would harm the country after Partition.
Option (3) Article 356 gave the Centre the powers to take over a state administration on the recommendation of the Chief Minister. — False. Article 356 let the Centre take over a state administration on the recommendation of the Governor. The Chief Minister had no such role in it.
Option (4) The states could levy and collect certain taxes on their own, including land and property taxes and sales tax. — True. Under fiscal federalism the states could levy and collect some taxes on their own, such as land and property taxes and sales tax.
NCERT (2026-27): “4. The Powers of the State “The Draft Constitution provided for three lists of subjects: Union, State, and Concurrent. The subjects in the first list were to be the preserve of the Central Government, while those in the second list were vested with the states. As for the third list, here Centre and state shared responsibility. However, many more items were placed under exclusive Union control than in other federations, and more placed on the Concurrent list too than desired by the provinces. The Union also had control of minerals and key industries. Besides, Article 356 gave the Centre the powers to take over a state administration on the recommendation of the Governor.” “… The states, meanwhile, could levy and collect certain taxes on their own: these included land and property taxes, sales tax, and the hugely profitable tax on bottled liquor.” |