Drawing on Bernier's descriptions, an eighteenth-century Western thinker argued that rulers in Asia enjoyed absolute authority over their subjects, kept in subjugation and poverty. Identify the idea and the thinker.
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 2
The correct answer is Option (2) → Oriental despotism - Montesquieu
Option (1) Asiatic mode of production - Karl Marx — Incorrect. The Asiatic mode of production was Karl Marx's concept of the nineteenth century. It deals with the state taking the surplus of village communities, which the question does not describe.
Option (2) Oriental despotism - Montesquieu — Correct. Montesquieu, a French philosopher of the eighteenth century, drew on Bernier to form the idea of oriental despotism. Under it, Asian rulers held absolute authority over subjects kept in subjugation and poverty.
Option (3) Oriental despotism - Karl Marx — Incorrect. The idea is right, but the thinker is wrong. Oriental despotism came from Montesquieu; Marx came a century later and built on it.
Option (4) Asiatic mode of production - Montesquieu — Incorrect. The thinker is right, but the idea is wrong. Montesquieu developed oriental despotism; the Asiatic mode of production was Marx's later concept.
NCERT (2026-27): “6.1 The question of landownership … “This idea was further developed as the concept of the Asiatic mode of production by Karl Marx in the nineteenth century. …” |