Choose the option that correctly transforms this sentence from direct speech to indirect speech:-
The economist said, “Social media platforms are responsible for the rise in conspicuous consumption and household debt this year.”
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 4
The correct answer is Option (4) → The economist said that social media platforms were responsible for the rise in conspicuous consumption and household debt that year.
Reporting a statement in indirect speech:
| Change | Direct | Indirect | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reporting verb | said, “ ” | said that | “Said” stays, and the statement is joined with that. The inverted commas go. |
| Tense change | are responsible | were responsible | The reporting verb is in the past, so the present “are responsible” moves back to were responsible. |
| Words of nearness | this year | that year | “This year” becomes that year. |
| Full sentence | The economist said, “Social media platforms are responsible for the rise in conspicuous consumption and household debt this year.” | The economist said that social media platforms were responsible for the rise in conspicuous consumption and household debt that year. |
The speaker’s words are reported faithfully. "Social media platforms", "conspicuous consumption" and "household debt" stay, and nothing is added.
Example: She said, “I am busy this week.” → She said that she was busy that week.
Why the Other Options are Incorrect?
Option 1: The economist said that this year social media platforms are responsible for the rise in conspicuous consumption and consequently household debt. — Incorrect.
- "Are" is not moved back to were, and "this year" is not changed to that year.
- It adds "consequently", a cause-and-effect link the economist never stated.
Option 2: The economist said social media platforms are responsible for the rise in conspicuous consumption and consequently household debt in that year. — Incorrect.
- "Are" is not moved back to were, although the time word has already become "that year".
- It adds "consequently", which changes what the economist said.
Option 3: The economist declared that social media is responsible for the rise in conscious consumption and rise in household debt in recent years. — Incorrect.
- "Conscious" (aware) replaces "conspicuous" (showy, meant to be noticed), so the meaning changes.
- "Social media platforms" is cut to "social media", "is" is not moved back, and "this year" becomes "in recent years", a different time.