Arrange the following alcohols in the increasing order of their reactivity with HBr.
A. Benzyl alcohol
B. p-nitrobenzyl alcohol
C. p-methylbenzyl alcohol
D. p-chlorobenzyl alcohol
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → B, D, A, C
Benzyl alcohols react with HBr by the SN1 path. The –OH group is protonated and leaves as water, and the benzylic carbocation formed is then attacked by \( \ce{Br^{-}} \):
\( \displaystyle \ce{ArCH2OH + HBr -> ArCH2Br + H2O} \)
The more stable the carbocation, the faster the reaction. A group at the para position changes this stability:
Electron donating group (–CH3, +I and hyperconjugation): pushes electrons towards the positive carbon, stabilises the carbocation and increases the rate.
Weakly withdrawing group (–Cl, −I stronger than +R): slightly destabilises the carbocation and lowers the rate.
Strongly withdrawing group (–NO2, −I and −R): strongly destabilises the carbocation and makes the reaction slowest.
Combined order of reactivity:
\( \displaystyle p\text{-}\ce{NO2} < p\text{-}\ce{Cl} < \ce{H} < p\text{-}\ce{CH3} \)
Matching the given alcohols:
(B) p-nitrobenzyl alcohol: strong electron withdrawing group
(D) p-chlorobenzyl alcohol: weak electron withdrawing group
(A) benzyl alcohol: no substituent
(C) p-methylbenzyl alcohol: electron donating group
Shortcut: The nitro compound (B) is slowest and the methyl compound (C) is fastest, which leaves Options (2) and (3). Chlorine withdraws electrons, so D is slower than A. That gives Option (3).