Consider the following statements about the debate on the powers of the Centre and the states:
(A) K. Santhanam from Madras most eloquently defended the rights of the states.
(B) Santhanam felt the fiscal provisions would impoverish the provinces since most taxes, except land revenue, had been made the preserve of the Centre.
(C) A member from Bombay warned that "the Centre is likely to break" since powers had been excessively centralised.
(D) Santhanam argued that by transferring some of its functions to the states, the Centre could be made stronger.
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 4
The correct answer is Option (4) → A, B and D only
(A) K. Santhanam from Madras most eloquently defended the rights of the states. — Correct. K. Santhanam from Madras was the most eloquent defender of the rights of the states.
(B) Santhanam felt the fiscal provisions would impoverish the provinces since most taxes, except land revenue, had been made the preserve of the Centre. — Correct. Santhanam held that the fiscal provisions would impoverish the provinces, because most taxes except land revenue went to the Centre.
(C) A member from Bombay warned that "the Centre is likely to break" since powers had been excessively centralised. — Incorrect. The warning that "the Centre is likely to break" came from a member from Orissa, who felt powers had been too centralised.
(D) Santhanam argued that by transferring some of its functions to the states, the Centre could be made stronger. — Correct. Santhanam said an overburdened Centre cannot work well. Transferring some functions to the states would in fact make it stronger.
NCERT (2026-27): “4.1 “The centre is likely to break” “As for the states, Santhanam felt that the proposed allocation of powers would cripple them. The fiscal provisions would impoverish the provinces since most taxes, except land revenue, had been made the preserve of the Centre. Without finances how could the states undertake any project of development? “I do not want any constitution in which the Unit has to come to the Centre and say ‘I cannot educate my people. I cannot give sanitation, give me a dole for the improvement of roads, of industries.’ Let us rather wipe out the federal system and let us have Unitary system.” Santhanam predicted a dark future if the proposed distribution of powers was adopted without further scrutiny. In a few years, he said, all the provinces would rise in “revolt against the Centre”.” “Many others from the provinces echoed the same fears. They fought hard for fewer items to be put on the Concurrent and Union lists. A member from Orissa warned that “the Centre is likely to break” since powers had been excessively centralised under the Constitution.” |