Select the option which best expresses the following sentence in the Direct Speech.
She asked her daughter if she wanted ice-cream.
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 1
The correct answer is Option (1) → She said to her daughter, "Do you want ice-cream?"
Indirect question to direct speech:
| Change | Indirect | Direct | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reporting verb | asked | said to | Asked becomes said to, and the words spoken go inside inverted commas. |
| Question form | if she wanted | Do you want ...? | If is dropped and the sentence becomes a real question with do and a question mark. |
| Tense change | wanted | want | The past wanted goes back to the present want, the tense the mother used. |
| Pronoun change | she | you | The daughter is spoken to, so she becomes you. |
| Full sentence | She asked her daughter if she wanted ice-cream. | She said to her daughter, “Do you want ice-cream?” |
Example: He asked me if I liked tea. → He said to me, “Do you like tea?”
Why the Other Options are Incorrect?
Option 2: She said to her daughter, "Did she want ice-cream?" — Incorrect.
- It keeps "she", although the mother is speaking to her daughter.
- It keeps the past tense instead of going back to the present.
Option 3: She said to her daughter, "Did she wanted ice-cream?" — Incorrect.
- After did, the verb must be in the base form (want), not "wanted".
- The pronoun "she" is also wrong.
Option 4: She said to her daughter, "Does she want ice-cream?" — Incorrect. The tense is right, but "she" should be "you", since the daughter is the person spoken to.