‘Ranjeet runs a factory producing denim shirts. The business is doing well and he intends to expand by diversifying into denim dresses and denim bags.’
Which organisation structure would be suitable for his expanded organisation, and why?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 2
The correct answer is Option (2) → Divisional structure, because each division is self-contained and develops expertise in all its functions
| Option | Reason |
|---|---|
| Option (1) Functional structure, because it makes training easier as the focus is on a limited range of skills. Incorrect. | Easier training is a merit of a functional structure, because its focus is only on a limited range of skills; Ranjeet is adding dresses and bags, a large variety of products, so a functional structure does not suit his expanded firm. |
| Option (2) Divisional structure, because each division is self-contained and develops expertise in all its functions. Correct. | Each division is self-contained because it develops expertise in all functions related to a product line; shirts, dresses and bags can each run as such a division, so a divisional structure suits Ranjeet’s expanded firm. |
| Option (3) Functional structure, because it leads to minimal duplication of effort, which lowers cost. Incorrect. | Minimal duplication of effort is a merit of a functional structure, because it gives economies of scale; Ranjeet’s firm will make a large variety of products, so this merit does not make a functional structure suit his expansion. |
| Option (4) Divisional structure, because it leads to minimal duplication of activities, which lowers cost. Incorrect. | A divisional structure does not lower cost through minimal duplication, because it may lead to an increase in costs from duplication of activities across products; so this reason cannot justify it for Ranjeet’s firm. |
NCERT Extract (2026-27 Edition): Correct option (2) Divisional Structure: “Each division is self-contained as it develops expertise in all functions related to a product line.” “Suitability: Divisional structure is suitable for those business enterprises where a large variety of products are manufactured using different productive resources. …” Wrong options (1), (3) and (4) Functional Structure > Advantages: “(d) It leads to minimal duplication of effort which results in economies of scale and this lowers cost.” “(e) It makes training of employees easier as the focus is only on a limited range of skills.” Divisional Structure > Disadvantages: “(b) It may lead to increase in costs since there may be a duplication of activities across products. …” |