Mercury is not considered as transition metal however it has tendency to react with chlorine to form chlorides X and Y. X reacts with KI to give red ppt while Y doesn’t react. On the contrary, Y reacts with NH4OH to give a black ppt. Predict the formula of X and Y :
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 4
The correct answer is Option (4) → X = HgCl2 , Y = Hg2Cl2
Mercury forms two chlorides: mercury(II) chloride, HgCl2 (corrosive sublimate, soluble in water) and mercury(I) chloride, Hg2Cl2 (calomel, insoluble). In mercury(I) the cation is the dimer \( \ce{Hg2^{2+}} \) with an Hg–Hg bond, so “HgCl” is not a correct formula.
X gives a red precipitate with KI: \( \ce{HgCl2} \) gives scarlet-red mercury(II) iodide, which dissolves in excess KI as \( \ce{K2[HgI4]} \) (Nessler’s reagent):
\( \displaystyle \ce{HgCl2 + 2KI -> HgI2 v + 2KCl} \)
\( \displaystyle \ce{HgI2 + 2KI -> K2[HgI4]} \)
Y turns black with NH4OH: calomel disproportionates; finely divided black mercury and white amidomercury(II) chloride are formed together, so the solid looks black:
\( \displaystyle \ce{Hg2Cl2 + 2NH3 -> Hg + Hg(NH2)Cl + NH4Cl} \)
So X = HgCl2 and Y = Hg2Cl2.
Why the other options are incorrect
Option (1) X = Hg2Cl2 , Y = HgCl — Incorrect. X and Y are swapped, and HgCl is not a real formula of mercury(I) chloride.
Option (2) X = Hg2Cl2 , Y = HgCl2 — Incorrect. The two are swapped: it is \( \ce{HgCl2} \) that gives the red \( \ce{HgI2} \), and \( \ce{Hg2Cl2} \) that blackens with ammonia.
Option (3) X = HgCl , Y = HgCl2 — Incorrect. HgCl is not a correct formula, and \( \ce{HgCl2} \) does not give a black product with ammonia (it gives a white precipitate).
Note: The question is from beyond the NCERT textbook.