Read the passage given below and answer the question.
Saksham, a newly appointed servicemen at M/s. Ghaziabad Petrol Station, G.T. Road, usually encounters problems while performing his job, like swiping the card when customers pay; generally forgetting to bring down the meter to zero before filling the petrol tanks of various vehicles; considerable amount of petrol spills while filling the petrol tank and so on. Overall, he doesn't respond in the manner as expected. Hence, customers get irritated and often complain about him. Saksham feels sad that despite his best efforts, he is not being able to perform his job properly. Saksham was appointed on the request of one of the close relatives of Petrol Pump Manager. Hence, the Petrol Pump Manager tries to improve Saksham's performance through maintaining good personal relations with him and thus to achieve goals of the organisation. Otherwise Petrol Pump Manager likes to give orders and expects his subordinates to obey them without any contradiction. He believes reward and punishment both can be given depending upon the result.
The leadership style usually followed by the Petrol Pump Manager is :
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → Dogmatic Leadership style
Option (1) Participative Leadership style — Incorrect. A participative (democratic) leader makes decisions in consultation with subordinates. This manager gives orders and does not ask for opinions.
Option (2) Free-rein Leadership style — Incorrect. A free-rein leader gives subordinates a high degree of independence. This manager keeps control and gives orders.
Option (3) Dogmatic Leadership style — Correct. The manager likes to give orders and expects his subordinates to obey them without any contradiction, and believes reward and punishment both can be given depending upon the result. This is the dogmatic (autocratic) leader.
Option (4) Free-Lancer Leadership style — Incorrect. Free-lancer is not a style of leadership.
Note: The case study is taken from the chapter ‘Staffing’, but this question is based on the chapter ‘Directing’. However, since it is a case-study based question, all the questions on this case study are tagged to the chapter the case study is taken from. NCERT (2026-27 Edition): “(i) Autocratic or Authoritarian leader An autocratic leader gives orders and expects his subordinates to obey those orders. If a manager is following this style, then communication is only one-way with the subordinate only acting according to the command given by the manager.” “This leader is dogmatic, i.e., does not change or wish to be contradicted. His following is based on the assumption that reward or punishment both can be given depending upon the result. This leadership style is effective in getting productivity in many situations like in a factory where the supervisor is responsible for production on time and has to ensure labour productivity. Quick decision-making is also facilitated.” “(ii) Democratic or Participative leader A democratic leader will develop action plans and makes decisions in consultation with his subordinates. He will encourage them to participate in decision-making. …” |