Sita and Geeta are two close friends and both are graduate working women. Sita is an economics graduate and doing research in economics while Geeta is a customer relation manager in a multinational company. On 1st January, 2023 both the friends decide to go out for a dinner to celebrate new year. Geeta is fond of Ice-Cream (Orange bar) and has decided to buy it from a street vendor at ₹10/unit after discount. She has also offered it to Sita but Sita refused as she was having a throat infection.
Geeta has requested Sita to apply economics principles and to tell her when she should stop consuming more ice-cream. On consuming the 3rd unit of Ice-cream, Geeta has obtained additional satisfaction of 18 utils while the marginal utility of a rupee is 2 utils.
State the condition of consumer equilibrium in case of single commodity which is being used by Sita to suggest her friend Geeta whether to consume more units of Ice-cream or not.
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → Price of the Good = Marginal Utility of the good (in Rupees)
A consumer of one good is in equilibrium when the satisfaction from the last unit, valued in rupees, equals its price. Marginal utility is counted in utils, and price in rupees. So utils are first turned into rupees by dividing by the marginal utility of a rupee.
Option (1) Price of the Good = Marginal Utility of the good (in utils) — Incorrect. This sets rupees against utils. The two are in different units. They can be compared only after the utils are turned into rupees.
Option (2) Price of the Good = Marginal Utility of the Rupee (in utils) — Incorrect. The marginal utility of a rupee is the satisfaction from one more rupee. It is used to turn utils into rupees, but it says nothing about the good itself.
Option (3) Price of the Good = Marginal Utility of the good (in Rupees) — Correct. If the unit is worth more than its price, buying it adds to her gain. If it is worth less, it was not worth buying. She stops at the point where the two are equal.
Option (4) Price of the Good = Marginal rate of Substitution — Incorrect. The marginal rate of substitution (MRS) is the amount of one good a consumer gives up to get one more unit of another. Her total utility stays the same. It belongs to the indifference curve analysis of two goods, not to one good measured in utils.
Note: None of the NCERT books (2026-27, 2025-26, 2023-24 or pre-rationalised) uses the unit ‘util’. They also do not state the equilibrium condition for one good in this form. It is the standard condition of cardinal utility analysis: marginal utility of the good ÷ marginal utility of a rupee = price of the good.