Read the following passage and answer the question.
Master Industries developed a new product, ‘Memory Sharpen Kit’, for kids. Mr. Shankar, the sales manager of the company, was asked to achieve target sales of 1000 kits in one month. He designed a sales plan for the kit without consulting his sales staff. He even refused to hear their suggestions and asked them to just follow his instructions. It led to frustration among the sales staff and, as a result, the sales target was not achieved on time. However, he made sure that every salesperson took orders from him alone and not from the other managers. He expects his colleagues to get work out of subordinates and yet has a differential treatment for each person. Mr. Shankar often bypasses the formal levels of authority and sends messages directly to junior staff, even when there is no emergency.
When Mr. Shankar sends messages directly to junior staff, skipping the managers in between, even when there is no emergency, he goes against which principle of Fayol?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 4
The correct answer is Option (4) → Scalar chain
Formal messages normally pass through every level from the top to the bottom; a direct contact that skips the levels is allowed only in an emergency.
| Option | Reason |
|---|---|
| Option (1) Unity of Command. Incorrect. | Unity of command is about receiving orders from only one superior; sending messages directly to junior staff is about the route of messages, not the number of bosses, so unity of command is not broken. |
| Option (2) Unity of direction. Incorrect. | Unity of direction is about one head and one plan for activities with the same objective; skipping levels says nothing about plans, so unity of direction is not broken. |
| Option (3) Order. Incorrect. | Order is about a place for everything and everyone; skipping levels has nothing to do with where people or things are kept, so order is not broken. |
| Option (4) Scalar chain. Correct. | The chain should not be violated in normal formal communication, and the gang plank is allowed only in an emergency; he skips the levels with no emergency, so he breaks scalar chain. |
NCERT Extract (2026-27 Edition): Correct option (4) (ix) Scalar Chain: “According to Fayol, this chain should not be violated in the normal course of formal communication. However, if there is an emergency then ‘E’ can directly contact ‘O’ through ‘Gang Plank’ as shown in the diagram.” Wrong options (1) and (3) (iv) Unity of Command: “The principle of unity of command states that each participant in a formal organisation should receive orders from and be responsible to only one superior.” (x) Order: “The principle of order states that ‘A place for everything (everyone) and everything (everyone) in its (her/his) place’.” |