Practicing Success

Target Exam

CUET

Subject

History

Chapter

Modern India: Understanding Partition

Question:

Read the passage and answer the question:

The Pakistan demand was formalised gradually. On 23 March 1940, the League moved a resolution demanding a measure of autonomy for the Muslim-majority areas of the subcontinent. This ambiguous resolution never mentioned partition or Pakistan. In fact, Sikandar Hayat Khan, Punjab Premier and leader of the Unionist Party, who had drafted the resolution, declared in a Punjab assembly speech on 1 March 1941 that he was opposed to a Pakistan that would mean “Muslim Raj here and Hindu Raj elsewhere ... If Pakistan means unalloyed Muslim Raj in Punjab then I will have nothing to do with it.” He reiterated his plea for a loose (united), confederation with considerable autonomy for the confederating units.

Why did the discussions about the transfer of power between the Britishers and the Indian leaders break down in 1945?

Options:

Due to Jinnah’s unrelenting demand the League had an absolute right to choose all the Muslim members of the Executive Council.

Due to Jinnah's demand that there should be a kind of communal veto in the Council, with decisions opposed by Muslims needing a two-thirds majority.

Both options, 1 and 2

Neither 1 nor 2

Correct Answer:

Both options, 1 and 2

Explanation:

The correct answer is Option 3 - Both options, 1 and 2

Option 1- Due to Jinnah’s unrelenting demand the League had an absolute right to choose all the Muslim members of the Executive Council.
Option 2- Due to Jinnah's demand that there should be a kind of communal veto in the Council, with decisions opposed by Muslims needing a two-thirds majority.
Option 3- Both options, 1 and 2
Option 4- Neither 1 nor 2

 

When negotiations were begun again in l945, the British agreed to create an entirely Indian central Executive Council, except for the Viceroy and the Commander -in-Chief of the armed forces, as a preliminary step towards full independence. Discussions about the transfer of power broke down due to Jinnah’s unrelenting demand that the League had an absolute right to choose all the Muslim members of the Executive Council and that there should be a kind of communal veto in the Council, with decisions opposed by Muslims needing a two-thirds majority. Given the existing political situation, the League’s first demand was quite extraordinary, for a large section of the nationalist Muslims supported the Congress (its delegation for these discussions was headed by Maulana Azad), and in West Punjab members of the Unionist Party were largely Muslims. The British had no intention of annoying the Unionists who still controlled the Punjab government and had been consistently loyal to the British.