Consider the following statements about Buchanan and his accounts of the countryside:
(A) Buchanan was an employee of the British East India Company.
(B) The costs of Buchanan's travels were borne by the local zamindars, since they needed the information he collected.
(C) Buchanan's assessment of what was necessary was shaped by the commercial concerns of the Company and modern Western notions of progress.
(D) Buchanan carefully observed local practices of salt-making and iron-ore mining.
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 1
The correct answer is Option (1) → A, C and D only
(A) Buchanan was an employee of the British East India Company. — Correct. Buchanan was an employee of the British East India Company, so his reports must be read with that in mind.
(B) The costs of Buchanan's travels were borne by the local zamindars, since they needed the information he collected. — Incorrect. The costs of his travels were borne by the East India Company, because it needed the information he collected. Zamindars did not pay for them.
(C) Buchanan's assessment of what was necessary was shaped by the commercial concerns of the Company and modern Western notions of progress. — Correct. His idea of what was necessary was shaped by the Company's commercial concerns and modern Western notions of progress, so he wanted forests turned into farmland.
(D) Buchanan carefully observed local practices of salt-making and iron-ore mining. — Correct. He searched for commercially valuable minerals and carefully observed local salt-making and iron-ore mining.
NCERT (2026-27): “2.3 The accounts of Buchanan “When Buchanan wrote about a landscape, he most often described not just what he saw, what the landscape was like, but also how it could be transformed and made more productive – what crops could be cultivated, which trees cut down, and which ones grown. And we must remember that his vision and his priorities were different from those of the local inhabitants: his assessment of what was necessary was shaped by the commercial concerns of the Company and modern Western notions of what constituted progress. He was inevitably critical of the lifestyles of forest dwellers and felt that forests had to be turned into agricultural lands.” |