In a monastery near Vaishali, a group of monks have spent several days discussing whether to accept a gift of land from a wealthy merchant. Before joining the order, some of them had been craftspeople and labourers, and one had been a prince. Every monk has spoken, yet they still do not agree. The eldest monk reminds them that their order runs its affairs on the pattern of the ganas and sanghas of the region.
Following that pattern, how would the matter now be settled?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → By putting the question to a vote among them
Option (1) By the order of the eldest monk present — Incorrect. In the sangha all members were equal once they joined. The eldest monk could guide the talk, but he could not decide alone.
Option (2) By the ruling of the king of the region — Incorrect. A king had no say inside the sangha. Even a former prince became an equal monk, so a royal ruling does not fit the pattern.
Option (3) By putting the question to a vote among them — Correct. In the ganas and sanghas, members first tried for consensus through discussion. When that failed, the matter was decided by a vote, which is the step the monks have reached here.
Option (4) By the decision of the lay gahapatis who give alms — Incorrect. Lay gahapatis gave alms to the monks but were not members of the order. They took no part in its decisions.
NCERT (2026-27): “6. Followers of the Buddha … |