Which of the following are disadvantages of divisional structure?
(A) Divisional heads gain experience in a narrow area, which restricts their training for top positions.
(B) It becomes difficult to fix responsibility in cases of poor performance of a division.
(C) Conflict may arise among different divisions with reference to allocation of funds.
(D) It may lead to increase in costs since there may be a duplication of activities across products.
(E) It may lead to slower decision making, as each division has to refer matters to the top management.
(F) A divisional manager may ignore organisational interests in a bid to assert his independence.
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 4
The correct answer is Option (4) → (C), (D) and (F) only
(A) Divisional heads gain experience in a narrow area, which restricts their training for top positions. — False. Product specialisation develops varied skills in a divisional head and prepares him for higher positions; this is an advantage.
(B) It becomes difficult to fix responsibility in cases of poor performance of a division. — False. The structure helps in fixation of responsibility in cases of poor performance; this is an advantage.
(C) Conflict may arise among different divisions with reference to allocation of funds. — True.
(D) It may lead to increase in costs since there may be a duplication of activities across products. — True.
(E) It may lead to slower decision making, as each division has to refer matters to the top management. — False. Each division functions as an autonomous unit, which leads to faster decision making; this is an advantage.
(F) A divisional manager may ignore organisational interests in a bid to assert his independence. — True.
NCERT Extract (2026-27 Edition): Correct statements (C), (D) and (F) Divisional Structure – Disadvantages: “Conflict may arise among different divisions with reference to allocation of funds …” “It may lead to increase in costs since there may be a duplication of activities across products. Providing each division with separate set of similar functions increases expenditure.” “… may gain power and in a bid to assert his independence may ignore organisational interests.” Incorrect statements (A), (B) and (E) Divisional Structure: “Product specialisation helps in the development of varied skills in a divisional head and this prepares him for higher positions.” “It also helps in fixation of responsibility in cases of poor performance of the division and appropriate remedial action can be taken.” “It promotes flexibility and initiative because each division functions as an autonomous unit which leads to faster decision making.” |