Read the following passage and answer the question.
Kavya has just taken charge as the manager of Gokul Dairy, a large milk company. Earlier, each section head ran his section in his own way, and the same costly mistakes were made year after year. Kavya studies how management principles have worked in similar situations and uses them to settle recurring problems quickly. She asks for facts and figures with every proposal and decides only after weighing them. She matched the number of milk tankers on each route to the milk actually collected there, so that no tanker ran half empty. The dairy’s ice-cream plant had been running at a loss for years; she sold it and put all her effort into milk products, the dairy’s real strength. She also set up a school and a health centre for the families of the farmers who supply milk to the dairy. On the shop floor, she shares a part of the dairy’s gains with the workers, listens to their suggestions and rewards those that cut costs. She has found that the same principles work as well in the dairy as they did in the government hospital where she worked earlier.
Which principles of F.W. Taylor does Kavya follow with her shop-floor workers?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 1
The correct answer is Option (1) → Harmony, not discord and Cooperation, not individualism
Option (1) Harmony, not discord and Cooperation, not individualism — Correct. Sharing a part of the gains with workers is harmony, not discord, which brings complete harmony between management and workers. Listening to suggestions and rewarding those that cut costs is cooperation, not individualism.
Option (2) Science, not rule of thumb and Harmony, not discord — Incorrect. Harmony, not discord is right. But science, not rule of thumb means replacing trial-and-error with one best method found by study; Kavya’s shop-floor steps are about gains and suggestions.
Option (3) Cooperation, not individualism and Development of each and every person to his or her greatest efficiency and prosperity — Incorrect. Cooperation, not individualism is right. But development of each person is about scientific selection and training of workers, which the passage does not describe.
Option (4) Science, not rule of thumb and Development of each and every person to his or her greatest efficiency and prosperity — Incorrect. Neither principle is shown. Kavya introduces no new work method, and she does not select or train workers.
NCERT (2026-27 Edition): “(ii) Harmony, Not Discord: Factory system of production implied that managers served as a link between the owners and the workers. Since as managers they had the mandate to ‘get work done’ from the workers, it should not be difficult for you to appreciate that there always existed the possibility of a kind of class-conflict, the mangers versus workers. Taylor recognised that this conflict helped none, the workers, the managers or the factory owners. He emphasised that there should be complete harmony between the management and workers. Both should realise that each one is important. To achieve this state, Taylor called for complete mental revolution on the part of both management and workers. It means that management and workers should transform their thinking. In such a situation even trade unions will not think of going on strike etc. Management should share the gains of the company, if any, with the workers. At the same time workers should work hard and be willing to embrace change for the good of the company. …” “(iii) Cooperation, Not Individualism: There should be complete cooperation between the labour and the management instead of individualism. This principle is an extension of principle of ‘Harmony not discord’. Competition should be replaced by cooperation. Both should realise that they need each other. |