Law of demand is violated when?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → Negative income effect is greater than substitution effect.
The law of demand says that, other things being equal, demand for a good falls when its price rises. It rises when its price falls. The law is violated when the income effect works against the substitution effect and is stronger. Such a good is called a Giffen good.
A fall in price has two effects. Under the substitution effect, the consumer buys more of the good because it is now relatively cheaper. Under the income effect, her purchasing power rises. For a normal good this adds to demand. For an inferior good, whose demand falls as income rises, it cuts demand, and this is a negative income effect.
Option (1) Income effect is negative. — Incorrect. This only makes the good inferior. If the substitution effect is stronger, demand and price still move in opposite directions.
Option (2) Substitution effect is negative. — Incorrect. The substitution effect moves demand opposite to the price: a cheaper good is bought more. This supports the law of demand.
Option (3) Negative income effect is greater than substitution effect. — Correct. The income effect outweighs the substitution effect, so demand becomes positively related to price.
Option (4) Negative income effect is less than substitution effect. — Incorrect. The substitution effect wins here, so demand and price remain inversely related. The law of demand holds.
NCERT (2026-27): “Law of Demand: Law of Demand states that other things being equal, there is a negative relation between demand for a commodity and its price. In other words, when price of the commodity increases, demand for it falls and when price of the commodity decreases, demand for it rises, other factors remaining the same.… …A rise in the purchasing power (income) of the consumer can sometimes induce the consumer to reduce the consumption of a good. In such a case, the substitution effect and the income effect will work in opposite directions. The demand for such a good can be inversely or positively related to its price depending on the relative strengths of these two opposing effects. If the substitution effect is stronger than the income effect, the demand for the good and the price of the good would still be inversely related. However, if the income effect is stronger than the substitution effect, the demand for the good would be positively related to its price. Such a good is called a Giffen good.” |