Two friends were discussing government intervention in the market through price control. Arushi said that market-determined prices are different from price ceiling and price floor. Anisha disagreed. Who is correct, and why?
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 3
The correct answer is Option (3) → Arushi is correct, because price ceiling and price floor are limits imposed by the government, while market-determined prices come from demand and supply
A market-determined price comes from demand and supply. A price ceiling and a price floor are limits fixed by the government, so they are different from the market price.
Option (1) Anisha is correct, because a price floor is set at the level where market demand equals market supply — Incorrect. The price where market demand equals market supply is the equilibrium price. A price floor is set higher than the market-determined price.
Option (2) Arushi is correct, because a price ceiling is fixed above the market-determined price — Incorrect. Arushi is right, but this reason is wrong. A price ceiling is fixed below the market-determined price.
Option (3) Arushi is correct, because price ceiling and price floor are limits imposed by the government, while market-determined prices come from demand and supply — Correct. Both are government-imposed limits, an upper one and a lower one.
Option (4) Anisha is correct, because a price ceiling is the price at which the market clears — Incorrect. At a ceiling below p*, buyers want more than sellers offer. The market does not clear; there is excess demand.
NCERT (2026-27): “5.2.1 Price Ceiling It is not very uncommon to come across instances where government fixes a maximum allowable price for certain goods. The government-imposed upper limit on the price of a good or service is called price ceiling. Price ceiling is generally imposed on necessary items like wheat, rice, kerosene, sugar and it is fixed below the market-determined price since at the market-determined price some section of the population will not be able to afford these goods.” “5.2.2 Price Floor For certain goods and services, fall in price below a particular level is not desirable and hence the government sets floors or minimum prices for these goods and services. The government-imposed lower limit on the price that may be charged for a particular good or service is called price floor. Most well-known examples of imposition of price floor are agricultural price support programmes and the minimum wage legislation. Through an agricultural price support programme, the government imposes a lower limit on the purchase price for some of the agricultural goods and the floor is normally set at a level higher than the market-determined price for these goods. Similarly, through the minimum wage legislation, the government ensures that the wage rate of the labourers does not fall below a particular level and here again the minimum wage rate is set above the equilibrium wage rate.” |