Identify the correct combination of demerits of Divisional Structure.
(A) Promotes flexibility and facilitates expansion and growth of new divisions
(B) Product specialisation and managers become over powered
(C) Leads to increase in cost and conflict may arise among various divisions
(D) Conflict may arise as interest of two departments may not be compatible and inflexibility of people
(E) Less emphasis on overall objectives and costly
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 4
The correct answer is Option (4) → (C) only
(A) Promotes flexibility and facilitates expansion and growth of new divisions — Not a demerit (Incorrect). These are two merits of the divisional structure. Each division works on its own, and new divisions can be added easily.
(B) Product specialisation and managers become over powered — Not a correct demerit (Incorrect). Product specialisation is a merit: it builds varied skills in a divisional head. So the statement mixes a merit with a demerit.
(C) Leads to increase in cost and conflict may arise among various divisions — A demerit of the divisional structure (Correct). Both are demerits: conflict may arise among divisions over funds, and costs go up because the same activities are repeated in each division.
(D) Conflict may arise as interest of two departments may not be compatible and inflexibility of people — Not a demerit of the divisional structure (Incorrect). These are demerits of the functional structure: conflict of interests between departments, and inflexibility.
(E) Less emphasis on overall objectives and costly — Not a demerit of the divisional structure (Incorrect). Less emphasis on overall enterprise objectives is a demerit of the functional structure.
NCERT (2026-27 Edition): “Disadvantages: … (a) Conflict may arise among different divisions with reference to allocation of funds and further a particular division may seek to maximise its profits at the cost of other divisions.” “(b) It may lead to increase in costs since there may be a duplication of activities across products. Providing each division with separate set of similar functions increases expenditure.” “(c) It provides managers with the authority to supervise all activities related to a particular division. …” “Key Terms … Divisional structure groups activities on the basis of products. The advantages are integration, product specialisation, greater accountability, flexibility, better coordination and more initiative. …” “Functional structure … (a) A functional structure places less emphasis on overall enterprise objectives than the objectives pursued by a functional head. …” “(c) A conflict of interests may arise when the interests of two or more departments are not compatible. …” “(d) It may lead to inflexibility as people with same skills and knowledge base may develop a narrow perspective and thus, have difficulty in appreciating by other point of view. …” |