Read the passage carefully and answer the questions based on the passage:
Equality of the Marginal Rate of Substitution and the Ratio of the Prices
The optimum bundle of the consumer is located at the point where the budget line is tangent to one of the indifference curves. If the budget line is tangent to an indifference curve at a point, the absolute value of the slope of the indifference curve and that of the budget line are the same at that point. The slope of the indifference curve is the rate at which the consumer is willing to substitute one good for the other. The slope of the budget line is the rate at which the consumer is able to substitute one good for the other in the market. At the optimum, the two rates should be the same. To see why, consider a point where this is not so. Suppose the marginal rate of substitution at such a point is 2 and suppose the two goods have the same price. At this point, the consumer is willing to give up 2 mangoes if she is given an extra banana. But in the market, she can buy an extra banana if she gives up just 1 mango. Therefore, if she buys an extra banana, she can have more of both the goods compared to the bundle represented by the point, and hence, move to a preferred bundle. Thus, a point at which the MRS is greater, the price ratio cannot be the optimum. A similar argument holds for any point at which the MRS is less than the price ratio.
A consumer is willing to give up 4 bananas if it is given an extra mango, but in the market, if it gives up 6 bananas, this bundle will be considered.
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 4
The correct answer is Option (4) → Inferior bundle.
Two rates decide whether a bundle is the best one. The marginal rate of substitution (MRS) is the rate at which a consumer is willing to give up one good for another: here 4 bananas for an extra mango, so the MRS is 4. The price ratio is the rate at which she is able to exchange them in the market: here 6 bananas for a mango, so the price ratio is 6. The two rates are not equal, so she can still move to a better bundle.
Option (1) Preferred bundle. — Incorrect. That is the bundle she moves to, not the one she has now.
Option (2) Optimum bundle. — Incorrect. At the optimum, the MRS equals the price ratio. Here 4 is not equal to 6.
Option (3) Most preferred bundle. — Incorrect. The most preferred bundle is the optimum. A bundle she can still improve cannot be the most preferred one.
Option (4) Inferior bundle. — Correct. Her MRS (4) is less than the price ratio (6), so she can gain by trading. If she gives up one mango, the market gives her 6 bananas. But 4 bananas are enough to keep her as well off as before, so she gets 2 bananas extra. By buying fewer mangoes and more bananas, she moves to a preferred bundle. So her present bundle is an inferior bundle.
Note 1: Here ‘inferior’ means a less preferred bundle. It has nothing to do with an inferior good (a good whose demand falls when income rises).
Note 2: The passage of this question is taken from the section ‘Equality of the Marginal Rate of Substitution and the Ratio of the Prices’ of the chapter ‘Theory of Consumer Behaviour’ of the NCERT book. Read the chapter thoroughly, boxes and case studies included. This question only turns the book’s mango-and-banana example round: here the MRS is below the price ratio.
NCERT (2026-27): “Equality of the Marginal Rate of Substitution and the Ratio of the Prices … If the budget line is tangent to an indifference curve at a point, the absolute value of the slope of the indifference curve (MRS) and that of the budget line (price ratio) are same at that point. Recall from our earlier discussion that the slope of the indifference curve is the rate at which the consumer is willing to substitute one good for the other. The slope of the budget line is the rate at which the consumer is able to substitute one good for the other in the market. At the optimum, the two rates should be the same. To see why, consider a point where this is not so. Suppose the MRS at such a point is 2 and suppose the two goods have the same price. At this point, the consumer is willing to give up 2 mangoes if she is given an extra banana. But in the market, she can buy an extra banana if she gives up just 1 mango. Therefore, if she buys an extra banana, she can have more of both the goods compared to the bundle represented by the point, and hence, move to a preferred bundle. Thus, a point at which the MRS is greater, the price ratio cannot be the optimum. A similar argument holds for any point at which the MRS is less than the price ratio.” “Where on the budget line will the optimum bundle be located? The point at which the budget line just touches (is tangent to), one of the indifference curves would be the optimum.9 To see why this is so, note that any point on the budget line other than the point at which it touches the indifference curve lies on a lower indifference curve and hence is inferior. Therefore, such a point cannot be the consumer’s optimum.” |