Choose the most appropriate passive construction of the given sentence:
The old watchman still remembers the Collector garlanding him at the Republic Day function in 1998.
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 4
The correct answer is Option (4) → The old watchman still remembers being garlanded by the Collector at the Republic Day function in 1998.
Passive of an -ing form after “remember”:
| Change | Active | Passive | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Main verb kept | still remembers | still remembers | “Still remembers” does not change, because the watchman is still the one remembering. Only the garlanding part changes to the passive. |
| -ing form made passive | the Collector garlanding him | being garlanded | “Him” is the watchman, who is already the subject, so it drops out. “Garlanding” becomes being + past participle (V3): “being garlanded”. |
| Agent (by ...) | the Collector | by the Collector | The Collector is named, so the doer comes after “by”. |
| Full sentence | The old watchman still remembers the Collector garlanding him at the Republic Day function in 1998. | The old watchman still remembers being garlanded by the Collector at the Republic Day function in 1998. |
Other verbs followed by an -ing form work the same way, like hate, avoid and mind. Example: Rahul hates people calling him by his nickname. → Rahul hates being called by his nickname.
Why the Other Options are Incorrect?
Option 1: The old watchman still remembers to be garlanded by the Collector at the Republic Day function in 1998. — Incorrect. After “remember”, “to be garlanded” points to something still to happen later. It cannot go with an event of 1998.
Option 2: The old watchman still remembers having garlanded the Collector at the Republic Day function in 1998. — Incorrect. This turns the meaning around. Now the watchman put the garland on the Collector.
Option 3: The old watchman is still remembered for being garlanded by the Collector at the Republic Day function in 1998. — Incorrect. “Is still remembered” makes the watchman the one whom others remember. In the given sentence, he is the one who remembers.