Out of the statements given below, identify the ones that can be used to criticize Malthusian Theory of Population Growth.
(A) Economic growth could outstrip population growth
(B) The historical experience of Asian countries
(C) Problem like poverty and starvation were caused by the unequal distribution of economic resources rather that by population growth
(D) Both population and agricultural production grew in arithmetic progression
(E) Changing pattern of population growth caused by controlling outbreaks of pandemic
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 2
The correct answer is Option 2: (A), (C), (E) Only
The Malthusian Theory of Population Growth argued that population grows in geometric progression, while food production grows arithmetically, leading to inevitable poverty, famine, and starvation unless checked by natural or moral constraints. However, this theory has been widely criticized for several reasons:
-
(A) Economic growth could outstrip population growth – Correct. Technological advancement and improved agricultural productivity have enabled economic and food production growth to exceed population growth, contradicting Malthus's prediction.
-
(C) Problems like poverty and starvation were caused by the unequal distribution of economic resources rather than by population growth – Correct. Critics argue that poverty and hunger result more from social and economic inequality than from the number of people.
-
(E) Changing pattern of population growth caused by controlling outbreaks of pandemic – Correct. Modern medicine and public health have significantly altered population patterns and reduced mortality, which Malthus could not foresee.
The other options are incorrect or irrelevant:
-
(B) refers to a historical observation but doesn't directly critique Malthusian assumptions.
-
(D) incorrectly states that both population and agricultural production grew in arithmetic progression, which is not a part of Malthus's theory.