It may be incorrect to treat GDP as an index of the welfare of the country for the following reasons.
(A) Externalities.
(B) Distribution of GDP is not uniform.
(C) Monetary exchanges.
(D) Non-monetary exchanges.
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: option 1
The correct answer is Option (1) → (A), (B) and (D) only
GDP is the value of goods and services produced within a country in a year. A higher GDP may seem to show greater well-being of the people, but it need not.
(A) Externalities. — Correct. Externalities are benefits or harms that a firm or person causes to others, without being paid or penalised for them. An oil refinery may pollute a river and harm the people who use it. GDP does not take such harm into account.
(B) Distribution of GDP is not uniform. — Correct. A rise in GDP may be concentrated in the hands of very few individuals or firms. The income of the others may even fall, so the welfare of the whole country need not rise.
(C) Monetary exchanges. — Incorrect. Exchanges made with money are what GDP does record. So they give no reason to doubt it as an index of welfare.
(D) Non-monetary exchanges. — Correct. Domestic work done at home without pay and barter exchanges use no money. They are not counted in GDP, so GDP is underestimated.
NCERT (2026-27): “2.5 GDP and Welfare … So we may be tempted to treat higher level of GDP of a country as an index of greater well-being of the people of that country (to account for price changes, we may take the value of real GDP instead of nominal GDP). But there are at least three reasons why this may not be correct. 1. Distribution of GDP – how uniform is it: If the GDP of the country is rising, the welfare may not rise as a consequence. This is because the rise in GDP may be concentrated in the hands of very few individuals or firms. For the rest, the income may in fact have fallen. In such a case the welfare of the entire country cannot be said to have increased.… 2. Non-monetary exchanges: Many activities in an economy are not evaluated in monetary terms. For example, the domestic services women perform at home are not paid for. The exchanges which take place in the informal sector without the help of money are called barter exchanges. In barter exchanges, goods (or services) are directly exchanged against each other. But since money is not being used here, these exchanges are not registered as part of economic activity.… 3. Externalities: Externalities refer to the benefits (or harms) a firm or an individual causes to another for which they are not paid (or penalised). Externalities do not have any market in which they can be bought and sold. For example, let us suppose there is an oil refinery which refines crude petroleum and sells it in the market. … But in carrying out the production the refinery may also be polluting the nearby river. This may cause harm to the people who use the water of the river. … In this case, the GDP is not taking into account such negative externalities.…” |